Designing under an NEC contract: what you must submit and what you stay liable for
How contractor design works under NEC clauses 21 to 23, why acceptance does not move liability, and what Option X15 changes.
On this page
If part of your NEC contract includes design, the rules are in clauses 21 to 23 (same numbers in NEC4 ECC and NEC3). You only design what the Scope (the document setting out what you must deliver) says is yours. You send the Project Manager (the person who runs the contract for the Client) the design particulars and wait for acceptance before starting the related work. After acceptance you are still liable for the design.
In plain English
The Project Manager can reject your design on two grounds only, but accepting it does not take any liability off you.
The clauses
| Clause | Effect |
|---|---|
| 21.1 | The Scope names the parts you are responsible for designing |
| 21.2 | You send particulars to the Project Manager, and the related work waits until they are accepted |
| 21.3 | Staged submissions are allowed where each stage can be judged on its own |
| 22.1 | The Client may use and copy the design for the stated purposes, with matching rights from your subcontractors |
| 23.1 | When instructed, you submit the design of an item of Equipment |
How acceptance works
The stated reasons for not accepting are that the design does not comply with the Scope or does not comply with the applicable law. If the refusal is only because the Project Manager likes a different answer, that can be a compensation event under 60.1(9). Replies are on the usual reply periods, and a late reply may be a 60.1(6) event. Even so, wait before starting the work, and raise the delay instead.
Acceptance does not shift liability
Your duty to Provide the Works and your liability for your design stay where they were (14.1). "You accepted it" is not a defence for a design Defect. A design Defect arises when the work does not follow the Scope, or work you designed does not meet the law or the design you had accepted. If the accepted design falls short of what the Scope asks for, the shortfall is still yours. The reverse holds where the Client wrote the design inside the Scope and that design is faulty: then the risk sits with the Client.
Changes to the design
| Change | Compensation event? |
|---|---|
| The Project Manager alters the Client's requirements | Yes, under 60.1(1) |
| You decide to revise your own design | No |
| You amend your design so it complies with the Client's Scope | No |
Keep the Client's design and your own clearly separate on paper.
The standard of care: Option X15
Without X15 the test is the result: if the design misses what the Scope states, it is a Defect however skilled the designer was. With X15 you escape liability for a design Defect if you can show the designer worked with the skill and care that professionals on similar works normally apply. NEC3 places the burden of proof on you, and the NEC4 version adds record keeping and professional indemnity insurance duties. Correcting a Defect that was not your liability gives you a compensation event under X15.2.
A practical checklist
- Show every design package on the programme with the date you need it accepted.
- Confirm the Scope says which particulars to supply, and in how much detail.
- Do not start related work early.
- Give subcontractors the same user rights (22.1).
- Keep records of design decisions: under X15 they are your defence.
Example
A fictional basement box culvert must stay dry to a stated standard. Your designer picks a waterproofing system and the Project Manager accepts it. Eleven months after Completion damp appears and the chosen system is to blame. Without X15 you repair it at your own cost. With X15 you may be off the hook, provided your design records show competent skill and care.
Related guides
- The Project Manager refused to accept our design
- Defects under NEC
- Our own designer is late with drawings
- The Scope explained
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
