The Supervisor has notified a Defect I disagree with: what to do
Step-by-step guidance for a Contractor who thinks a notified Defect is not a Defect: respond in writing, protect your position and keep working.
On this page
The Supervisor has notified a Defect and you think the work complies with the Scope. Perhaps the Scope never asked for what the Supervisor wants, or the work was built to an instruction or an accepted design. This guide is written from the Contractor's side. A Subcontractor in the same position is dealing with the Contractor in the same way, so substitute the roles.
The short answer
Respond in writing quickly, and say exactly why you think it is not a Defect, pointing to the Scope, drawing or instruction. Silence can be read as agreement, and the time to correct a notified Defect may be running while you argue. At the same time, protect yourself on programme and cost in case the disagreement ends up going against you.
What to do, step by step
- Read the notification. Check it came from the Supervisor and identifies the work clearly. A vague notification is worth querying in writing straight away.
- Note the dates. Write down the date you received it and the date the defect correction period in the Contract Data will run to. If the Defect was notified before Completion, the period starts at Completion; if after, it starts on notification (clause 44.2 in NEC4, 43.2 in NEC3). Do not guess the length: read your Contract Data and any Z clauses.
- Check the Scope. Find the part of the Scope (Works Information in NEC3), the specification and any accepted design that applies. Check whether any later instruction, compensation event or change altered the requirement.
- Check your own records. Look for inspection and test records, approvals, as-built information and the date and location of the work.
- Reply in writing. Under clause 13, send a communication in the form required by your contract. State that you do not accept the item is a Defect, give the Scope reference or the instruction, and invite the Supervisor to reconsider. Keep the tone factual and in line with the spirit of mutual trust and co-operation in clause 10.2 (10.1 in NEC3).
- Ask for a meeting if it helps. A short site meeting with the Supervisor and a note of what was agreed solves many of these quickly. Follow it up in writing.
- Consider a compensation event. If the Supervisor's position is really an instruction to do something the Scope does not require, check the compensation event list in clause 60.1 and the notification time limit in clause 61.3. Do not let the eight-week period slip while you wait for an answer.
- Decide whether to correct under protest. If the work is small and the dispute is not worth the delay, you can correct it and reserve your position in writing. If the correction is significant, consider whether to hold off until the point is resolved. That depends on the correction period and on how the contract treats uncorrected Defects. If you had access and let the period run out, the Project Manager assesses the Client's cost of having others correct it and you pay that (clause 46.1 in NEC4, 45.1 in NEC3), which can be well above your own cost, so get commercial advice first. Another option is to propose accepting the Defect, with a quotation for reduced Prices or an earlier Completion Date (clause 45 in NEC4, 44 in NEC3), but that needs the Project Manager's agreement and does not stop the correction period running.
- Escalate if needed. If you cannot agree, the dispute resolution Option in your contract applies. Under W2 you can go to adjudication at any time, but under W1 a four-week limit runs from becoming aware of the action you dispute. In NEC4, W3 uses a Dispute Avoidance Board instead of adjudication. Take advice before using it.
What to record
- The Supervisor's notification, with its date and how it was received
- The Scope clauses, drawings and specifications you rely on
- Inspection and test records, photographs of the work and sign-offs
- Any instruction, change or accepted design that affects the requirement
- Every reply and meeting note, with dates
- The cost and time of any correction you carry out
What not to do
- Do not ignore the notification or answer verbally only.
- Do not argue the point with the Supervisor on site and leave it there.
- Do not correct the work silently without recording your position.
- Do not refuse to correct without understanding the consequence for uncorrected Defects.
- Do not mix the Defect argument with a general complaint about the Supervisor. Stick to the specific item.
When to get help
Speak to your commercial manager if the correction cost is significant or if the item looks like a change. Bring in a planner if the correction needs resources that clash with other work, or if a delay to Completion is possible. Take legal advice before starting any formal dispute process.
Example
A Contractor builds a chamber cover to the drawing issued for construction. The Supervisor notifies it as a Defect because a different cover type appears in a general specification. The Contractor replies within days, quoting the drawing revision, and points out that it was accepted by the Project Manager. It asks the Supervisor to withdraw the notification or confirm that a change is being instructed. The Supervisor then confirms an instruction for a different cover, and the Contractor notifies a compensation event.
Related guides
- Defects under NEC: how the process works in plain English
- Compensation events in plain English
- Avoiding disputes under NEC
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
