Weather Under NEC: When Bad Weather Is a Compensation Event

How the one-in-ten-year weather test in clause 60.1(13) works, what to set up in Contract Data, and why most bad weather stays your risk.

Compensation events and change3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. Check the Contract Data first
  3. Reading the numbers
  4. Working it through the month
  5. What people get wrong
  6. Related guides

Bad weather only becomes a compensation event if the recorded figures for a calendar month are rarer than a one-in-ten-year occurrence. Everything short of that is your risk. It is a numbers test under clause 60.1(13), not a judgement about whether the month felt dreadful, and it works the same way in NEC3 and NEC4.

Only the part beyond the one-in-ten level is paid for. Even when the test is passed, you do not recover the whole month.

In plain English

The contract names a weather station and a set of measurements. If a month's reading at that station beats what would be expected once in ten years, the extra is a compensation event. A wet month that is merely unpleasant is something you were meant to price.

Check the Contract Data first

Contract Data is the part of the contract where the project-specific details are filled in. Look at what your version says before any rain falls:

  • The measurements used for each calendar month. The standard form lists total rainfall in millimetres, days with more than 5mm of rain, days with a minimum air temperature below freezing, and days with snow lying. Others, such as wind, can be added.
  • Who supplies those measurements.
  • The weather data: past records for each month, the place they were taken and where to get them.
  • Assumed values for the ten-year level, used where no records exist.

The place may be a station miles from your site. That station decides the test. Your own rain gauge is useful for showing what happened on the job, but it cannot establish the event.

Reading the numbers

Each measurement is tested alone. Imagine a fictional bridge approach on Option A, with a Completion Date in September, and these figures for April:

Measurement Recorded One-in-ten level Result
Rainfall total 140mm 115mm Passes, 25mm over
Days over 5mm 12 10 Passes, 2 days over
Days below 0°C 3 8 Fails

Piling stops on days with over 5mm of rain, so the sensible measure is the two excess days, not all twelve. If those two days cost £6,000 each in running and standing costs, the Prices rise by £12,000 plus the Fee, and planned Completion moves two days. The other ten wet days stay with you.

Working it through the month

  1. Put the one-in-ten table for each month in the project file at the start. Agree how it is calculated if the records do not state it directly.
  2. Watch the cumulative figure as the month builds up. Rainfall can cross the line part way through, so give an early warning when that looks likely.
  3. Collect the official figures from the named supplier once the month ends.
  4. Notify promptly. The eight-week time bar runs from when you become aware the event has happened. Waiting for the publisher is no excuse to delay.
  5. Record daily what was working, what stopped and why, including ground state and resources.
  6. Assess only the excess, against the Accepted Programme current on the day you notify.

Separating excess from ordinary rain is the hard part, because rain does not fall in layers. Explain your method plainly. A reasoned approach usually beats a precise-looking figure with nothing behind it.

What people get wrong

  • Comparing with the wrong period. The test is that calendar month against the same month in past records, not the annual average.
  • Claiming a bad week. Measurements are monthly, so a terrible week in a dry month probably will not pass.
  • Claiming the whole month. Only the excess counts.
  • Measuring too late. A reading recorded after the Completion Date does not qualify.
  • Reaching for other events. Physical conditions exclude weather, and prevention rarely works for a weather near-miss.
  • Leaving Contract Data blank. No station or no data source invites an argument.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?