Late Reply From the Project Manager: Compensation Event 60.1(6)

When a slow answer from the Project Manager or Supervisor becomes a compensation event, and what you need to prove before it is worth notifying.

Compensation events and change3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. Four things must be true
  3. Which clock applies
  4. Worked example
  5. What people get wrong
  6. Related guides

A late reply is a compensation event under clause 60.1(6), but only if the Project Manager or Supervisor failed to answer one of your communications within a period the contract sets. It only changes your money or dates if the delay actually cost you something. Being kept waiting is not enough on its own.

The Project Manager is the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day. The Supervisor is the person who checks that the work meets the Scope, the document that says what you must deliver. The wording of this event is effectively the same in NEC3 and NEC4.

In plain English

If the contract says someone must answer you by a certain date and they don't, you may have a compensation event. You then have to show what the silence did to your costs, your Completion Date or a Key Date.

Four things must be true

  1. You sent the communication. A slow answer from the Client itself, or a slow answer to something the Project Manager sent you, is not covered.
  2. The contract demands a reply. Clause 13.3 sets the period for reply where a reply is required, and clause 13.4 covers anything you submit for acceptance. A courtesy update or a casual question starts no clock.
  3. The period ran out. A prompt refusal still counts as a reply. If the refusal is for a reason the contract does not allow, a different event may fit, so look at 60.1(9).
  4. It had an effect. Under clause 61.4 the assessment needs a change to Defined Cost (the contract's measure of your actual cost), Completion or a Key Date.

Which clock applies

What you sent Time allowed
Something needing a general reply The period for reply in the Contract Data
A submission for acceptance The same period, unless the contract says otherwise
A programme for acceptance Two weeks (clause 31.3), and NEC4 adds a deemed acceptance route
A compensation event notice or a quotation The periods in clauses 61.4 and 62.3, with deemed outcomes after a further notice

An extension to a reply period under clause 13.5 only works if both sides agree before the reply is due. Agreeing afterwards does not undo the lateness. Many contracts change these periods, so read your Contract Data and Z clauses (the contract's added amendments) first. The related guide on the period for reply explains how to track them.

Worked example

A drainage subcontractor on a fictional car park scheme, Option A, with a two-week reply period. On 3 March it submits a revised pipe bedding detail for acceptance. The Project Manager's reply is due on 17 March and arrives on 24 March, a week late.

  • If bedding work was not due until mid-April, the event exists but nothing changes. The Prices and dates stay put.
  • If the gang was booked for 18 March and that work was critical, planned Completion slips by about a week, less any float. You would add the standing cost of the idle gang and the Fee.
  • If the pipes themselves were not on site until 26 March, the late reply did not cause the loss, so there is little to assess.

What people get wrong

  • Notifying every late answer. Where nothing moved, you gain little and annoy the other side. Log it and raise the pattern at a progress meeting.
  • Ignoring the one that bit. A short delay can still wreck a long-lead order. Check knock-on effects before dismissing it.
  • Treating a query form as a duty to reply. Tie your question to an ambiguity, a submission or a Scope requirement.
  • Accepting "noted" as an answer. A vague holding reply is not acceptance. Ask for a clear acceptance or reasons.

Because the late reply is silence rather than an instruction, the eight-week time bar in clause 61.3 applies. Count from the day you knew the reply had been missed. Keep a log of issue dates, due dates and actual dates, plus diaries and orders showing what you could not do while waiting.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?