Unexpected ground and site conditions: compensation event 60.1(12)
How the physical conditions event works, what you are taken to have known at tender, and how to prove only the excess is yours to claim.
On this page
Clause 60.1(12) gives you a compensation event when you hit physical conditions inside the Site boundary, excluding weather, which an experienced contractor would have judged too improbable at the Contract Date to price sensibly. Only the shortfall between what you found and a reasonable allowance is assessed. The numbering and substance are the same in NEC3 and NEC4.
Of all the events, this one is fought over most, because it rests on a view of risk rather than a plain fact. Z clauses, the contract's added amendments, often change or remove it, so read those first.
In plain English
You are not asked whether the ground surprised you. You are asked what a competent contractor, looking at the same information on the day the contract was made, would have expected. Anything it would have expected stays with you. Only the unreasonable-to-predict excess is paid.
The questions that decide it
| Question | Where | Practical point |
|---|---|---|
| Is it inside the Site? | 60.1(12) | A collapsed road outside the boundary needs another event. |
| Is it weather? | 60.1(12) | Weather has its own test. Ground flooded by a storm often falls here. |
| What are you taken to have known? | 60.2 | The Site Information, any public records it points to, what you would see on a walk round, and whatever a seasoned contractor would sensibly obtain. |
| Does the Site Information conflict? | 60.3 | Where information contradicts itself, you are taken to have assumed the kinder reading. |
| How unlikely was it? | 60.1(12) | Allowing for it would have been unreasonable. Being unusual is not enough. |
Most claims succeed or fail on clause 60.2. An old map the Site Information refers to counts as knowledge, as does a warning sign on the fence. Whether a neighbour's records or a geological memoir count depends on what an experienced contractor would obtain.
Evidence to gather
- Records made at the time: dated, located photographs, logs, surveys, test results and jointly measured quantities.
- The Site Information and every document it refers to.
- Your tender allowance, such as the method statement and assumptions. It does not decide the test but shows how risk was viewed.
- A short view from a geotechnical engineer on what those documents suggested.
Show the Project Manager the condition the moment you find it, ideally before it is excavated. An obstruction already removed from site is hard to prove.
Worked example
A fictional culvert replacement on Option C. Two of three boreholes show chalk at around 3 metres, the third at 2.5 metres. The excavation goes to 4 metres and you allowed for 250m³ of chalk, a reasonable reading. In fact chalk lies at 1.2 metres over the whole footprint, giving 900m³.
The difference assessed is 650m³. At an illustrative extra £40/m³ for breaking out, that is £26,000 before the Fee, plus the delay from the longer dig. The first 250m³ stays with you.
Had one borehole shown chalk at 1.2 metres, clause 60.3 would favour you on the conflict. Had all three shown it, there would be no event.
Timing and assessment
This one is yours to notify, so the time bar applies and you should raise it as soon as the condition shows. The dividing date is the notification date. If the extent is not yet known when the quotation falls due, the Project Manager may fix an assumption for you to price, with a correction available afterwards under 60.1(17). The time effect is often the biggest part, so tie it to planned Completion.
What people get wrong
- Using hindsight. The question is what the documents showed when the contract was made.
- Pricing the whole excavation. The difference rule means only the excess counts.
- Leaning only on boreholes. A utility search or old maps showing a former use can defeat a claim.
- Assuming thin information helps. An experienced contractor brings knowledge of the area.
- Thinking only natural ground counts. A buried tank or structure can qualify under the same test.
- Accepting a hasty rejection. A reply needs stated grounds. Ask for the facts to be considered.
Related guides
- Unforeseen ground conditions
- Contaminated ground under NEC
- Unmarked utilities found
- Reading Z clauses
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
