Unmarked utilities on site: is it a compensation event?

What to do when you hit a service that wasn't on any drawing, and how the NEC test for unforeseen physical conditions is applied to it.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

The excavator has hit something that isn't on any plan you were given. Before the commercial question, there is a safety one.

The short answer

Make it safe, then warn and notify. Unmarked services can be a compensation event under clause 60.1(12), but only if an experienced contractor could not reasonably have allowed for them when the contract started. One blank drawing proves little. The test looks at four sources the contract treats you as having checked, and that includes things you never actually opened if you could have got hold of them.

What to do, step by step

  1. Stop digging near it and treat it as live. Safety comes first, whatever the contract says.
  2. Identify the owner and whether it is live. Note who you spoke to and when.
  3. Photograph and survey it in place, showing depth and position, and invite the Project Manager to see it before it is moved or covered.
  4. Give an early warning if it could affect price or programme (clause 15.1).
  5. Notify the compensation event. The limit is eight weeks from becoming aware (clause 61.3), or seven under the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Subcontract. Do not wait for the owner's report.
  6. Prepare your case against the four sources that clause 60.2 says you are taken to have considered.

What to record

For each of the four sources, write a line on what it showed:

  • The Site Information the Client gave you: did it show this or a similar service, or warn that records were unreliable?
  • Any public information that document refers to
  • A visual inspection: manhole covers, markers, cabinets, patched surfaces, street lighting nearby
  • What you could reasonably have obtained: would an ordinary utility search have revealed it?

Where two sources disagree, clause 60.3 assumes you took the more favourable one for doing the work. Also keep owner contact notes, survey data and the dates of every instruction.

What not to do

  • Do not carry on digging without confirming it is dead.
  • Do not damage it. Damage to property of Others while providing the works is normally the Contractor's liability (clause 81.1). Tell your insurer.
  • Do not skip checks your own safe-digging procedure or the Scope required. If a survey would have found it, the delay is yours.
  • Do not assume it is an event if it lies outside the Site boundary or you are working under a Z clause that passes service risk to you.

When to get help

A commercial manager should prepare the one-page map of the four sources, because the Project Manager is likely to reject the notice as not a listed event. A planner should show the effect on the Accepted Programme, especially if you are waiting for the owner to divert the service. Take legal advice if the amount is large.

Example

A fence-line replacement beside a rail depot on Option A. The Site Information shows a power cable and a drainage run, and nothing at the post line. A site walk showed no covers or markers. The Contractor priced hand digging near the known services plus two small unrecorded crossings. On day six the augers hit a redundant telecom duct bank across the whole line. The owner takes three weeks to confirm and cut it. Only the work beyond the two-crossing allowance goes in the quotation, together with the delay the Accepted Programme shows. In a busy town street some unrecorded services might reasonably be expected, so the allowance would be larger there. On open farmland it would be nearly nil.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?