Contaminated ground found on site: your first steps and who pays

What to do when you uncover contamination, and how the NEC physical conditions test and the Site Information decide whether it is a compensation event.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

Your excavator has turned up stained soil, drums or a smell that shouldn't be there. Before you think about the contract, you have legal duties to protect people and the environment.

The short answer

Stop work in that area, make it safe and get your health, safety and environmental advisers in. Then tell the Project Manager and give an early warning. Contamination can be a compensation event under clause 60.1(12) if an experienced contractor could not reasonably have allowed for it when the contract started. NEC has no separate clause for it, so everything turns on what the Site Information and the Scope said.

What to do, step by step

  1. Stop and protect people. Treat unusual smells, staining, fibres, drums or oily water as hazardous until tested.
  2. Stop it spreading. Control runoff and stockpiles. Do not take material off site until it has been classified, because waste law applies whatever the contract says.
  3. Tell the Project Manager at once and give an early warning (clause 15.1). Your environmental adviser will say whether a regulator must also be told.
  4. Sample and map it. If you can, agree the test plan with the Project Manager so both sides trust the results.
  5. Notify the compensation event within eight weeks of becoming aware (clause 61.3; seven weeks under the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Subcontract). Do not wait for laboratory results.
  6. Ask for assumptions. If the extent is unknown when your quotation is due, the Project Manager can state assumptions (clause 61.6), which are corrected later if they prove wrong.

What to record

  • Photographs, sample locations and laboratory results
  • Waste classification records and transfer notes. They prove both quantity and cost
  • The site investigation reports and desk studies you were given, and anything they said about history of the land
  • Dates of every conversation with the Project Manager, advisers and regulators
  • Any instruction the Project Manager gives about treatment or removal

What not to do

  • Do not argue entitlement before you have made the area safe.
  • Do not assume the Client will handle disposal. Under clause 73.2 the Contractor has title to excavated and demolition material unless the Scope says otherwise, and that carries responsibility.
  • Do not rely on a report issued after the Contract Date to show what you should have known then. It can only show what was really there.
  • Do not stay silent about a former industrial history you noticed at tender stage.

When to get help

Bring in a commercial manager early. How the documents read decides the position:

What the documents show Likely position
Site Information reported this type and extent You were taken to have allowed for it. Only anything beyond it counts
Credible report found the ground clean Stronger case, subject to what an inspection or public records would have shown
Reports contradict each other Clause 60.3 assumes the condition more favourable for the work
Former industrial site, no investigation given Weaker. History is something a contractor could reasonably find
Scope puts all contamination on you Likely no event, or heavily limited. Read the words
Project Manager instructs extra treatment Compensation event under 60.1(1), whatever the ground test says

Many Clients move this risk with a Z clause, so read those first. Take legal advice if a regulator becomes involved, because environmental liability is separate from the contract.

Example

A pumping station platform on Option C. A report found slightly raised hydrocarbons in two trial pits and classed the made ground as non-hazardous, and the Contractor priced 3,000 m3 of disposal on that basis. Digging finds a buried fuel tank and 800 m3 of hazardous soil between the pits, with nothing visible at the surface. The assessment covers the extra cost of hazardous over non-hazardous disposal for the 800 m3, plus tank removal, testing and the critical delay. The other 2,200 m3 stays as priced. Had the desk study mentioned a former fuel depot on that spot, the case would have been much harder. All figures are invented.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?