Instruction received but no compensation event notified

The Project Manager gave an instruction that changes the Scope but did not notify an event. Here is how to notify it yourself and protect your position.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Is every instruction an event?
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

You have been instructed to do something extra, and the instruction arrived with no mention of a compensation event. Do not assume the extra work is on you.

The short answer

Notify the event yourself under clause 61.3. The Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract) should have notified it at the time of the instruction under clause 61.1, but the missing notice does not remove your entitlement. Carry out the instruction and put your notice in today. Clause numbers match across NEC3 and NEC4, except that NEC4 puts the instruction to submit quotations in 61.2.

What to do, step by step

  1. Obey the instruction. Clause 27.3 requires you to follow an instruction given under the contract. A pricing disagreement is no reason to stop.
  2. Notify today. Give the instruction reference, date and the clause. An event arising from an instruction, certificate or changed decision escapes the eight-week bar, but there is nothing to gain by waiting.
  3. Diary the answer. You should hear back within a week, or two under the NEC4 subcontract. Silence lets you notify the failure.
  4. Start recording from the day of the instruction. It is the dividing date under clause 63.1 whenever you notified.
  5. Warn if there are knock-on effects. Use an early warning under clause 15.1 if time or cost may move beyond the obvious.

A sample notice, invented: "Instruction PMI-051 of 2 March requires a new cable containment route along the north corridor and carried no notification. We notify under clause 61.3 that this is a compensation event under 60.1(1), and ask you to reply within the clause 61.4 period and instruct quotations. We are proceeding with the work."

Is every instruction an event?

What the instruction does Compensation event?
Alters what the Scope requires Yes (60.1(1))
Stops work or alters a Key Date Yes (60.1(4))
Concerns a historic object found on Site Yes (60.1(7))
Reverses a previous decision Yes (60.1(8))
Orders a search and no Defect is found Yes (60.1(10)), subject to an exception
Alters the Scope so a Defect can stay No, excluded
Alters your own design at your request or to fit the Client's Scope No, excluded
Asks for a revised programme or the removal of someone Not by itself
Repeats what the Scope already demands No event, because nothing has changed

What to record

  • The instruction itself and any covering email.
  • The Scope clause or drawing it changed, set beside it.
  • Dates when work started and was affected.
  • Your notice and when it was sent.

What not to do

  • Do not stop work until the money is agreed.
  • Do not accept "it is a clarification" without comparing the wording line by line.
  • Do not accept "deal with it at final account". NEC does not work that way.
  • Do not forget to chase the reply period.

If you hear "you left it too long", point to the exemption in clause 61.3. A separate outer limit applies under clause 61.7.

When to get help

If notifications are habitually missing, raise it at a progress meeting first, since it is often an oversight. Involve a commercial manager if the Project Manager says it is not an event, because that decision can be disputed and dispute time limits are short under W1.

Example

A fictional Option B fit-out. The Project Manager emails an instruction to relocate a stud wall, with no notice. You carry out the work and notify under 60.1(1) two days later, attaching the email. The Prices are assessed from the instruction date, so costs incurred in the interim count as actual cost.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?