Does the time bar still apply if the PM should have notified?

The eight-week time bar is lifted only for events arising from the Project Manager's own communications. Knowing about an event is not enough.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

You are late with a compensation event notice, and your argument is that the Project Manager knew all about it and should have notified it. Be careful: that argument is weaker than it sounds.

The short answer

The eight-week limit is switched off only for events that spring from the Project Manager's or Supervisor's own communication. For every other event it stays on, however well the Project Manager knew what was going on. So the question is the source of the event, not what the Project Manager knew. Send your notice today whichever side of the line you are on.

What to do, step by step

  1. Check which wording you have. NEC4 and the NEC4 subcontract lift the limit for events arising from an instruction or notification, a certificate, or a changed decision. The April 2013 NEC3 print names instruction, certificate, changed decision and corrected assumption, but not notification. The June 2005 NEC3 print is closer to the argument in this guide, but in practice points back to the duty in clause 61.1. Z clauses can change all of this.
  2. Sort your event.
Where the event comes from Is the limit lifted?
A Scope-changing instruction (60.1(1)) Yes, lifted
An instruction to stop, or to move a Key Date (60.1(4)) Yes, lifted
An instruction dealing with something found on Site (60.1(7)) Yes, lifted
A reversed earlier decision (60.1(8)) Yes, lifted
An instructed search where no Defect turns up (60.1(10)) Yes, because it comes from an instruction
A corrected assumption (60.1(17)) Lifted in NEC3's list; as a notification in NEC4
Late access, a late Client item, or Others (60.1(2), (3), (5)) No, even if the Project Manager saw it
A missed reply (60.1(6)) No
Ground, weather or a Client breach (60.1(12), (13), (18)) No
  1. Pin down the communication. Give its reference, date and author, and which category of the exemption it falls into.
  2. Say so if it was only spoken. Under clause 13.1 a conversation is a weak basis for calling something an instruction, so the exemption may not protect you. If you are still inside eight weeks, stay inside them.
  3. Separate mixed causes. Where some of the effect flows from a time-barred cause, split that part out now.

Remember the long-stop in clause 61.7, which catches every event: under NEC3 nothing can be notified after the defects date, and in the NEC4 subcontract nothing after the Defects Certificate.

What to record

  • The actual instruction, certificate or decision rather than a note about it.
  • For a changed decision, the earlier decision as well.
  • The Scope clause or drawing it changed.
  • When your work was hit, because for this type of event the dividing date is the day of the communication.

What not to do

  • Do not treat the Project Manager's knowledge as an exception. It is not one.
  • Do not delay because you believe you are exempt.
  • Do not over-claim by folding a barred cause into an exempt one.
  • Do not leave a missed eight weeks unaddressed. Treat it as a separate problem.

When to get help

If you have missed the eight weeks and no exemption fits, speak to a commercial manager promptly. Waiver and fairness arguments need legal advice, because the contract does not make knowledge an exception, though it may influence what the Client will agree.

Example

A fictional Option A roadworks job. You send: "We notify this event under clause 61.3. It arises from your instruction PMI-112 of 4 February, which changed the Scope for the car park surfacing. Clause 61.3 does not limit the time for notifying an event of this kind." The Project Manager replies it was only a "design development note". Ask what it was, under which clause it was sent, and whether you are to disregard it. If it was an instruction, the exemption applies. If not, you return to the Scope.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?