Notice sent by email, not the communication system: is it valid?
You emailed a notice but the NEC contract requires the communication system. What the clause 13 position is and how to fix it quickly.
On this page
You sent a compensation event notification, an early warning or another notice by email. Now you notice that the contract names a communication system, such as a project portal, and says communications go through it. In NEC4 that system is stated in the Scope. Was your notice valid? This guide is written from the Contractor's side; a Subcontractor should check what the subcontract says.
The short answer
It depends on the contract wording, and you should not rely on the email being enough. Under clause 13.1 a communication must be readable, capable of being copied and kept as a record, so an email can qualify. Under NEC4 13.2 a communication takes effect through the communication system the Scope specifies, if there is one; otherwise it takes effect on receipt at the last notified address or the address in the Contract Data. So an email sent outside a specified system may not count, however clear it is. NEC3 13.2 says nothing about a system: effect is on receipt at the last notified address, or the one in the Contract Data, so check how any system named in your Works Information or a Z clause fits with that. A notification must also be sent separately from other communications (13.7), so a notice buried in a progress report or a long email chain invites the argument that it was not validly given. The safe course is to resend through the system immediately and refer to the earlier email.
What to do, step by step
- Read the clause, the Scope and the Contract Data. Find what the contract says about the form of communications and the system to be used. Check for Z clauses that change it, and for any agreed alternative (for example, that email is accepted).
- Check how the other side has behaved. If the Project Manager has regularly accepted emails and acted on them, that is relevant. It is not a safe basis on its own, so do not rely on it.
- Resend through the system now. Submit the same notice, with the correct date of your resubmission, and say it is a resubmission of the notice emailed on the earlier date.
- Keep the original email. It shows when you first told the other side, which may matter for time limits.
- Check any time limits. A compensation event must be notified within eight weeks of becoming aware that it has happened (clause 61.3; seven weeks under the NEC4 subcontract). If you are still inside that period, resending fixes the problem. If not, see missed the eight-week deadline.
- Ask for acknowledgement. Ask the Project Manager to confirm they accept the notice as received on the earlier date, or at least to confirm receipt.
- Change your practice. Agree who submits through the system, and set a rule that nothing important goes by email only.
What to record
- The original email, its date and recipients, and any delivery or read receipt.
- The contract clause and Contract Data entry describing the system.
- The resubmission through the system, with its date and reference.
- Any response, including acceptance, rejection or silence.
- Examples of earlier emails the Project Manager acted on without objection.
- Evidence of any system outage, if that is why you used email.
What not to do
- Do not assume that an email is fine because "everyone uses email".
- Do not wait to see whether the Project Manager objects.
- Do not backdate the resubmission or pretend the first route was the system.
- Do not send the same notice through different routes with different wording.
- Do not treat the system as a formality. The period for reply (13.3), and the treated-acceptance routes that depend on a notified failure to reply, run from when the communication takes effect.
- Do not argue form over substance as your only fallback. Whether a court or adjudicator would accept an email depends on the contract and the facts.
When to get help
If the notice is a time-critical one, such as a compensation event close to the eight-week limit, speak to your commercial manager the same day. Take legal advice if the Project Manager rejects the notice on form alone and a significant sum depends on it.
Example
A Contractor emails a compensation event notification in week seven. In week eight, someone notices the Scope names a project portal. The same day, the Contractor submits the notification through the portal, noting the earlier email. It asks the Project Manager to confirm receipt. The Project Manager acknowledges and responds on the merits.
Related guides
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
