What you are liable for as the contractor under NEC

The four things NEC makes the Contractor liable for, how they sit against the Client's list, what changed from NEC3, and insurance and subcontractors.

Early warning and risk3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. The four main items
  3. Why the opening words matter
  4. What changed from NEC3
  5. Side by side
  6. A short example
  7. Subcontracting does not move the risk
  8. What to do with this list
  9. Related guides

Under NEC4 you, as Contractor, carry the liabilities in clause 81.1 unless the same matter is listed as the Client's. In practice that means claims from third parties arising from your work, loss of or damage to the works and your materials and equipment, damage you cause to the Client's other property, and injury to your own people. Read the Client's list first, because it takes priority.

In plain English

If your work causes it, or it happens to your site, your people or your kit, it is probably yours. If it is on the Client's list, such as war or a fault in their design, it is theirs.

The four main items

Your liability What it covers Everyday case
Claims from Others (third parties) linked to your work on the contract Anyone outside the contract who says your activity hurt them Grit from a saw settles on parked vehicles next door
Loss or damage to the works, Plant and Materials and Equipment Your own working environment until take over Flood damage to stored fittings and temporary works
The Client's other property, if your work is connected with the damage Harm your work does to existing assets A drill rig cracks the Client's boundary wall
Death or injury of your employees Employer's liability An operative falls from scaffold

Why the opening words matter

Your list applies only where the matter is not the Client's liability. Damage to the works generally falls on you, yet the same damage caused by war sits on the Client's list, so it is theirs.

What changed from NEC3

NEC3 had one sentence in 81.1: from the starting date until the Defects Certificate, any risk not carried by the Employer was the Contractor's. That worked as a catch-all. NEC4 swapped it for a written list.

NEC3 also had a duty at 82.1 to replace lost items and repair damage promptly. NEC4 clause 82 deals with recovering costs instead, but the Scope still has to be delivered, so damaged work must be made good.

Side by side

Matter Yours if The Client's if
Damage to the works Before take over, as the starting position War-type events, or the part has been taken over (with exceptions)
Claims from Others Your activities caused them The works' unavoidable effects, or the Client's own people's negligence
Design faults The design is yours It sits in the Scope the Client provided, or in an instruction changing it
Client-supplied items After you receive and accept them Until you receive and accept them

A short example

A mobile crane on a fictional pumping station job slews wrongly and its outrigger drops. It damages a neighbour's shed (£15,000), crushes valves you had stored on site (£6,000) and injures an operative. The Site Information was accurate and the Client had done nothing wrong.

  • The shed: a claim from Others connected with Providing the Works. Yours.
  • The valves: damage to your materials. Yours, with no compensation event.
  • The injury: yours, covered by employer's liability insurance and subject to reporting.

Should the Client pay the neighbour first, clause 82 lets it claim that sum back from you.

Subcontracting does not move the risk

Passing work to a subcontractor leaves you responsible for the whole of it (26.1). A subcontractor's carelessness is still your problem with the Client. Pass the liabilities down in an NEC subcontract or similar. The back-to-back subcontracts guide explains how.

What to do with this list

  1. Check your insurance against each of the four items.
  2. Look in the Contract Data for extra Contractor's liabilities and price them.
  3. Consider whether Option X18 limits your liability, and what it does not cap.
  4. Remember excesses and exclusions: what the insurer will not pay is still yours.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?