Who carries the risk under each NEC main option
How cost, quantity and overrun risk shift between Options A to F, a worked comparison and the risks that stay the same whichever option you use.
On this page
Your main option decides, more than anything else, how much of a cost overrun lands on you. At one end, Option A leaves most of it with you. At the other, Option E leaves it with the Client. Options C and D split it by a formula in between. What does not change with the option is the list of liabilities and most compensation events.
In plain English
The more of your price is fixed, the more risk you hold. The more you are repaid your actual cost, the more the Client holds. Target options share the difference.
Each option in a line or two
- Option A, priced with activity schedule. You are paid lump sums as activities finish. Overruns and quantity changes are yours.
- Option B, priced with bill of quantities. You are paid your rates times the quantities actually built. Your rates are your risk; quantity movement is largely the Client's, through re-measurement.
- Option C, target with activity schedule. You are repaid Defined Cost (the contract's definition of your actual, allowable cost) plus Fee, and any pain or gain against the target is shared in the proportions set in the Contract Data.
- Option D, target with bill of quantities. The same, except the target is re-measured, so quantity risk falls on the Client.
- Option E, cost reimbursable. The Client pays Defined Cost plus Fee and carries overruns and quantity risk. Administration for both sides is heaviest.
- Option F, management contract. You manage subcontractors and are repaid their cost. The Client carries that cost, while your own stated prices are yours.
Treat this as a general guide and read the main option clauses in your own contract. The admin load is also lighter under A and B than under C to F.
One event, four contracts
Say a pump set supplier raises its price by £80,000 between tender and order, for reasons nobody caused. It is not a compensation event, and no price adjustment option applies. On Options C and D, assume the share range puts half of any overrun on each side.
- A or B: you pay £80,000.
- C: you pay £40,000 and the Client £40,000.
- E: the Client pays £80,000 and you pay nothing, as long as the cost is not Disallowed Cost.
If the same rise were a compensation event, the Prices would be reassessed on Defined Cost. Under A, your exposure to the assessed effect largely disappears. Under C the target moves up as well, so the share is untouched by that amount. Under E you are paid the cost anyway, and the assessment just updates the forecast.
Movement inside an option
- B and D: quantity changes become compensation events in the cases listed at 60.4 to 60.7, and errors in the bill have their own rule.
- C, D and E: Disallowed Cost keeps some costs with you, for example putting right Defects after Completion.
- C and D: the share range in the Contract Data fixes the split (clause 54 in NEC4, 53 in NEC3).
Risks that do not depend on the option
Subject to the Contract Data, you face the same position on:
- physical conditions and weather, at 60.1(12) and 60.1(13);
- the two lists of liabilities;
- insurance;
- Defects and correction;
- the reasons and procedures for termination.
Secondary options then adjust the balance. X1 hands inflation to the Client, X2 hands over changes in the law, X7 adds delay damages and X18 caps your liability.
Picking with risk in mind
- A complete, stable design and a wish for price certainty point to A, or B where quantities may move.
- A wish to share risk and show your costs openly points to C or D.
- A scope too uncertain to price, an emergency say, points to E.
- If you hope to push a risk the market cannot price onto someone else, be careful: you will probably pay for it anyway.
Related guides
- How to choose an NEC main option
- Option A vs Option C
- Target cost and share
- The contractor's liabilities under NEC
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
