NEC or JCT: how the two contracts treat delay, change and notices

How NEC differs from JCT for the party doing the work, with a worked example and what to change in your habits when you switch.

NEC basics for newcomers3 min read

On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. The same event, handled twice
  3. Changes in habit
  4. Which suits whom
  5. Related guides

If you have worked on JCT jobs, the big shift is timing. NEC wants the cost and time effect of an event priced and agreed soon after it happens, tested against a live programme. JCT more often settles delay and loss once the effect is known, sometimes at the end. On UK buildings you will still meet JCT most often; public sector and infrastructure clients lean towards NEC. What follows is a broad comparison, taking the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract (ECC) as the NEC reference. There are numerous JCT forms, so check which one you hold.

Side by side

Topic NEC4 ECC Typical JCT
Form choice One contract, with a main Option for payment Separate forms by job size and type
Who runs it Project Manager, plus a Supervisor for quality Architect, Contract Administrator or Employer's Agent, usually backed by a cost consultant
Change and client-side events Every one is a compensation event, with price and time dealt with together Variations are valued, with delay and loss and expense on separate routes
Warnings Early warning by either side, kept on a register (15.1) Delay and loss notices are central
Programme Detailed and regularly revised, and the yardstick for delay (31, 32, 63.5) Usually lighter and less central
Late notice A contractor's notification can be lost after eight weeks (61.3) Notice needed, but entitlement is less often lost
Pricing change Forecast or actual Defined Cost plus Fee (63.1) Often contract rates where they apply

The same event, handled twice

Picture a pumping station refit. In week 10 the client changes the pipework layout, adding work and holding up the electricians for a week.

NEC4 ECC, Option A

  1. The Project Manager issues the instruction and notifies it as a compensation event (60.1(1)), requesting your quotation.
  2. You have three weeks to quote the forecast Defined Cost plus Fee, along with the effect on planned Completion (62.2, 62.3).
  3. The Project Manager has two weeks to reply. Suppose it agrees £12,000 and four days: the Prices and Completion Date then move and the assessment is normally fixed even if the real cost differs (66.3).

Typical JCT

  1. The administrator issues a variation instruction.
  2. A cost consultant values the extra work, normally using the contract rates.
  3. You give notice of delay, and a decision on extension of time may come well after the event.
  4. Disruption costs are claimed separately and can stay open until the final account.

Neither is automatically fairer. NEC demands more effort early and gives early certainty, though a forecast can be wrong. JCT can reflect what actually happened but leaves the number open for longer.

Changes in habit

  • JCT to NEC: you cannot save a claim for the final account. Build the eight-week notification check into your weekly routine from the start.
  • NEC to JCT: do not expect silence from the other side to settle things in your favour. NEC4 treats some silences as acceptance after a further notice (61.4, 62.6, 64.4, and 31.3 for programmes). That is specific to NEC.
  • Both ways: do not carry over defined terms. Completion, Defect and Prices have precise NEC meanings.

Which suits whom

NEC suits clients who will resource active management, face real uncertainty or want target or cost-based pricing within one family of forms. JCT suits building work with a mature design, a team that knows the form and a client wanting a traditional process. As the party doing the work, you rarely choose, so the practical question is how to adapt.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?