Missing cost records on an NEC cost contract: how to rebuild them

What to do when records for Defined Cost are missing on NEC Options C, D or E: where substitute evidence comes from and where to draw the line.

Payment and costScenario4 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Where substitute evidence comes from
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Other main Options
  9. Related guides

You have found a gap in the paperwork behind your Defined Cost, perhaps timesheets, invoices or proof of payment, and an application or inspection is coming.

The short answer

You do not automatically lose the money, but you are exposed. Cost that your accounts and records do not justify is Disallowed Cost. The outcome depends on whether other evidence can still show the cost was really incurred, was paid, and arose from the work. Start rebuilding now, because the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day) can inspect your records at any time in working hours (clause 52.3). Clause 52.2 lists what the cost-based Options expect you to hold, and the Disallowed Cost definition is at 11.2(26) in NEC4 and 11.2(25) in NEC3.

What to do, step by step

  1. Stop the gap growing. Find the cause, whether a leaver, a software change or a subcontractor sending nothing, and fix that first.
  2. Size it. Note what is absent, by cost code and by period. A £20,000 hole calls for a lighter touch than a £2m one.
  3. Check it is truly lost. Look through mailboxes, finance systems, supplier portals and phones before writing anything off.
  4. Rebuild from other sources, marking every reconstructed document as such.
  5. Tell the Project Manager before your next application if the sum is material. A reconstruction you disclose looks far better than one an audit discovers.

Where substitute evidence comes from

  • Lost invoice: ask the supplier for a duplicate or a statement. Strong once matched to a bank payment.
  • No proof of payment: bank statements, BACS files, card records and remittance advices. Strong.
  • Absent timesheets: payroll, gate or biometric logs, permit and induction records, site diaries. Good where two sources agree.
  • Plant hire dates: the hire firm's records, delivery tickets, fuel use, telematics and dated photos. Good.
  • Delivery tickets: the supplier's signed copies, and quantities visible in the finished work. Good for totals.
  • Shared staff time: organisation charts, meeting notes and emails showing what people did. Weaker, so expect a lower percentage.
  • Subcontractor compensation event assessments: the subcontractor's own copies and your correspondence. Variable.

What to record

  • A list of what is missing, by period and code.
  • The source used to rebuild each item.
  • The date each rebuilt document was prepared, who prepared it and what it relied on.
  • Your disclosure to the Project Manager.

What not to do

  • Never backdate. A record made today and dated last year, or a timesheet completed now as if at the time, is not a reconstruction. It exposes you to accusations much more serious than losing the money, and NEC4 contains its own provisions on corrupt acts.
  • Do not assume secondary evidence is automatically accepted. The contract does not list which documents count as accounts and records beyond clause 52.2 and the Scope, so you can argue that reliable secondary evidence qualifies, but expect "those are not the records you were told to keep" and sampling.
  • Do not spend more on proving a small item than it is worth.

When to get help

Take advice from your commercial director or a lawyer where the gap is large, the evidence is thin or someone proposes producing documents after the event. If the Project Manager disallows everything, ask for a reason on each line and follow the process for disallowed costs.

Example

A fictional Option C substation fence job. Six weeks of records for a crew of eight go missing when a document controller moves on. Payroll shows £36,000 paid. Gate logs put seven of the eight on site for nearly all of that period, and the supervisor's diary records the fence runs completed each day.

  • Backed by payroll and gate logs agreeing: £31,500. Realistically accepted, with the Fee following.
  • The eighth person, payroll alone: £4,500. Probably refused without something extra.

Accepting the loss of that last item, plus its Fee, may cost less than days of chasing it.

Other main Options

Under Options A and B, clauses 52.2 and 52.3 do not apply, so there is no standing duty to show accounts. But when you price a compensation event after the work is done, expect to support the Defined Cost before the dividing date. Keep records from the day any event starts.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?