The Project Manager disallowed your costs: how to respond

How to challenge Disallowed Cost on an NEC cost-based contract by matching your reply and evidence to the exact reason the Project Manager gives.

Payment and costScenario4 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Answering each reason
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

A certificate has come back with part of your Defined Cost struck out as "disallowed", and you want to know how to answer.

The short answer

Ask which part of the Disallowed Cost definition the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day) is relying on, and answer that part with evidence. The definition is a short list, and "too expensive" or "inefficient" are not on it by themselves. It sits at clause 11.2(26) of Options C, D and E in NEC4 and 11.2(25) in NEC3. This applies to cost-based contracts only.

What to do, step by step

  1. Get it itemised. You need the amount, the item and the reason for each. A single lump headed "disallowed" cannot be answered.
  2. Diary the dispute clock. Under Option W1, four weeks run from when you became aware. Under W2 there is no such limit to adjudicate.
  3. Sort the items into three piles: accepted, provable (with proof to follow) and disputed on the reason.
  4. Send proof with your next application, before the next assessment date. A wrong assessment is put right in a later certificate under clause 50.6.
  5. Look for repeats. If one reason points to a systemic issue, such as a payroll on-cost, fix it for every period.
  6. Reply in writing. Ask which limb of the definition applies, state your one-sentence disagreement and attach the record. Ask for correction in the next certificate under 50.6, and ask how much Fee was removed with the item.

Answering each reason

  • "There is no proof you paid it." The limb is cost not justified by your accounts and records. Reply with the bank entry or payment run, linked to the invoice.
  • "The subcontractor was overpaid." The limb is a payment that the subcontract itself did not require. Reply with the subcontract clause, the assessment and the quotation that support the sum.
  • "You did not follow the tendering procedure." The limb is cost arising only from ignoring a Scope procedure. Reply by showing the price would have been the same, for example through quotes or a market check.
  • "You failed to warn us." The limb is cost arising only from a missing required warning. Reply that a warning was given, or that giving one would not have avoided the cost.
  • "That is rework." This bites only after Completion, or where a Scope constraint was ignored. Reply with the date and confirm no constraint was involved.
  • "The plant sat idle." The limb is use beyond what was reasonable, or plant kept after a request to remove it. Reply with the allocation record and ask whether any written removal request exists.
  • "Your rates are too high." That is not a limb at all. Clause 52.1 and the schedule govern rates, so answer with open market evidence or the Contract Data rate.
  • "You have overspent the target." Also not a reason. The share mechanism deals with overspend.

What to record

  • The certificate with the disallowed items.
  • The Project Manager's stated reason for each.
  • Invoices, bank evidence, timesheets, allocation records and subcontract assessments.
  • Dates of your applications and replies.

What not to do

  • Do not argue "it is only a small amount" without checking the Fee that goes with it.
  • Do not ignore a repeat. The same issue will hit every month.
  • Do not let the dispute window pass while talking informally.
  • Do not accept "it is your job to prove it" for every limb. That is fair for records. For "only because" limbs, cause is the question, so both sides bring evidence.

When to get help

Use your commercial manager for routine queries. A monthly meeting between your QS and the Project Manager's cost team clears most of them before certification. Involve a lawyer for a point of principle or a large sum. A planner can help where the question is whether a cost followed from a delay.

Example

A fictional Option C job with a 10% fee percentage. £30,000 of cost is disallowed.

You lose the £30,000 of cost and £3,000 of Fee, so £33,000 comes out. With a 50% Contractor share, the cost side of the share calculation falls by that amount and you get £16,500 back, leaving a net cost of £16,500. On target contracts the blow is softened, but it still hurts more than if the item had stood.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?