Heading over target on an NEC Option C contract: what to do
What happens when costs run above the target on NEC Option C, and five practical actions that can cut the share you end up paying.
On this page
Your forecast of final cost on an Option C target contract is above the target, and you want to know how bad it can get and what can be done now.
The short answer
You keep being paid Defined Cost plus Fee as you go, and at the end you pay your share of any excess. Going over target is not a breach and does not stop payment. The final bill depends on how much of the gap is genuinely your overspend and how much comes from compensation events that have not yet lifted the target. Sorting out that split first usually reduces the number fastest. The share rules are at clause 54 in NEC4 (53 in NEC3).
What to do, step by step
- Hunt for un-notified events this week. The limit is eight weeks from when you became aware (clause 61.3), and only compensation events move the target. Question the site teams about changes, and go back through the Project Manager's instructions.
- Get the backlog implemented. Events that are notified but not yet reflected in the target are doing nothing for you. Chase quotations and assessments.
- Re-run the forecast honestly. Each Defined Cost forecast you send under clause 20 must explain what changed since the last one, and a sudden rise near Completion will draw questions.
- Give an early warning. NEC4 clause 15.1 lets you warn about a rise in your own total Defined Cost. It is optional, and it places the issue in front of the Client's team while options still exist.
- Propose savings. Clause 16.1 lets you suggest changing the Scope to cut cost. If it is accepted, 63.13 leaves the Prices alone where cost falls, so the saving goes through the share.
What to record
- Every change on site since the last forecast, with dates and who instructed it.
- The compensation event register, with the stage each event has reached.
- Your forecast build-up and the reasons it moved.
- Any Project Manager instruction you consider should have been a compensation event.
What not to do
- Do not let costs drift to protect cash now. Under Option C you settle your share in one go at Completion (54.3 in NEC4), which can be a sharp adjustment. Put a provision in your accounts as soon as it looks likely.
- Do not code costs to compensation events that do not belong there. An event's effect on the Prices comes from its forecast, not from where you book spend, and the Project Manager can see the ledger.
- Do not cut your record keeping to save overhead. Disallowed Cost falls wholly on you.
- Do not reduce quality to catch up. Correcting Defects after Completion is disallowed, whereas fixing them before Completion is generally still shared.
When to get help
Bring in your commercial manager as soon as the forecast crosses the target. Ask a planner to support quotations with programme evidence. Seek legal advice if the Client tries to cap or withhold payment, since the contract has no standard limit on what you are paid, although a Z clause may add one.
Example
A fictional Option C refurbishment. You pay half of any excess up to 110% of the target, and all of it above 110%.
| Now | If £250,000 of events are added | |
|---|---|---|
| Target (total of the Prices) | £2,000,000 | £2,250,000 |
| Forecast final cost | £2,400,000 | £2,400,000 |
| Excess over target | £400,000 | £150,000 |
| Half-share band | £200,000 x 50% = £100,000 | £150,000 x 50% = £75,000 |
| Full-share band | £200,000 | nil |
| Your bill | £300,000 | £75,000 |
Adding £250,000 of events cuts your bill by £225,000, because it also pulls the excess out of the harsher band. Read the bands in your own Contract Data part two, and compare like with like, since both figures include the Fee.
What to expect from the Client's side
Expect closer inspection of records (clause 52.3), a tougher look at idle plant and surplus staff, and probing of your quotations, since an implemented forecast fixes the target change for good (66.3). Offer a records walkthrough before you are asked, demobilise what you do not need, and build each quotation from the programme with assumptions shown.
Related guides
- Target cost and the Contractor's share
- Pain/gain share explained
- NEC Option C
- The compensation event process
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
