NEC Option D: a target that moves with measured quantities

How NEC Option D combines remeasurement with target cost sharing, what it means for your payments and share, and when it fits.

NEC Options and contract types3 min read

On this page
  1. Why the target behaves differently
  2. Example: a sea wall
  3. How you are paid
  4. Where the rules sit
  5. When it fits
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Related guides

Option D joins two ideas: Option B's measurement and Option C's shared savings and overruns. You are paid Defined Cost plus Fee as you go, but the target comes from a priced Bill of Quantities and gets remeasured while you work. At the end your final cost is set against the finished, measured target. This guide covers NEC4 ECC with NEC3 differences noted.

Why the target behaves differently

On Option C the target is the Activity Schedule total and only compensation events move it. On Option D it has two parts that change over the job:

  • each item's completed quantity multiplied by its rate;
  • the completed proportion of every lump sum item.

NEC calls the result the Total of the Prices, capitalised to distinguish it from your tender figure. You will not know it until measurement is finished.

Example: a sea wall

Say the tender Bill is £6,000,000. More rock armour is needed than expected, and by Completion the remeasured Bill stands at £6,400,000, with no compensation events along the way. Your Defined Cost plus Fee ends at £6,550,000. Only £150,000 is over target and that is what gets shared. On Option C the target would sit at £6,000,000 and the overrun would be £550,000, unless the extra quantity counted as a compensation event.

How you are paid

Monthly payment works as on other cost-based Options. The Project Manager, who runs the contract day to day for the Client, forecasts the cost you will have paid by the next assessment and adds the Fee. Measuring the Bill does not change the monthly amount due. Teams often assume measuring means being paid on measure, and it does not.

Both sides still need regular measurement, because it shows where the target is heading and therefore your likely share.

The open-book duties match Option C: records and inspection (52.2 and 52.3), forecasts of total Defined Cost, subcontract pricing information (26.4), and the Disallowed Cost definition (11.2(26)).

Where the rules sit

Rule NEC4 ECC NEC3 ECC
Working out and paying the share 54.5 onwards 53.5 to 53.8
Bill text carries no Scope weight 56.1 55.1
Quantity differences giving events 60.4, 60.5 60.4, 60.5
Bill mistakes 60.6, 60.7 60.6, 60.7
Events recorded as Bill changes 63.15 D63.13
Your accepted proposal leaves Prices unchanged 63.13 D63.11

The 0.5% test in 60.4 works here as in Option B. The consequence differs: a new rate shifts the target and leaves monthly payment alone.

When it fits

  • The design is measurable, yet quantities are doubtful enough that a fixed target would be a poor yardstick.
  • The Client wants cost sharing and is prepared to carry quantity risk.
  • Both sides can resource measurement and cost review.

It fits badly where you carry most of the design, since a Bill cannot be measured before a design exists. Look at Option C instead.

Common mistakes

  1. Carrying two sets of work for little gain. Measurement plus cost review needs resource. If quantity uncertainty is small, Option C is simpler.
  2. Forgetting measurement affects the target. More measured quantity raises it, so the Client will check your measurement. Keep it honest and well recorded.
  3. Expecting a monthly share. It is worked out at Completion and in the final amount due, never monthly.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?