Main contractor says it will pay you when the Client pays: is that allowed?

Pay when paid is normally ineffective under the Construction Act unless the payer is insolvent. See the dates, the pay less notice rules and your options.

Subcontractors and supply chainScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Quick guide to your position
  4. In the NEC4 subcontract itself
  5. What to record
  6. What not to do
  7. When to get help
  8. Example
  9. Related guides

The main contractor has said your certified money will follow when the Client pays them. You are the one carrying the cash flow, so it is worth knowing whether they are allowed to say that.

The short answer

Usually not. Section 113 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, known as the Construction Act, strips out pay-when-paid terms unless the party further up the chain is insolvent. A Client that is simply slow to pay is no reason for the main contractor to hold your money. Three things settle your position: does the Act cover your contract, is anyone insolvent, and did a valid pay less notice (a formal notice of what will be deducted) go out.

What to do, step by step

  1. Pin down the dates. With the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Subcontract and Option Y(UK)2, money is due 14 days after the assessment date and the final date for payment falls 14 days later, unless your Subcontract Data changes this.
  2. Look for a pay less notice. To be valid it must reach you at least seven days ahead of the final date, give the sum and show how it was calculated (Y2.3).
  3. The day after the final date, write to demand payment and state that interest is accruing under clause 51.2.
  4. Think about adjudication. The Act lets you refer a dispute whenever you choose.
  5. Think about suspending work, but only with advice. Section 112 needs seven days' written notice that gives your grounds, and the right falls away once you are paid in full. Suspending wrongly can be expensive.

Quick guide to your position

Situation Where you stand
Payment tied to Client receipt, Client solvent but slow The term does not work
A party above you is insolvent The condition may be allowed if your contract has one: read it and get advice
No conditional wording, main contractor just short of funds The money remains due, and lack of cash is not a ground to withhold
In-time pay less notice covering a sum you contest The argument is now about the amount, so adjudication is the route
Work outside the Act, such as a homeowner's own house, or outside Great Britain Other rules may apply, and Northern Ireland has separate legislation

When section 113 removes a term, the Scheme for Construction Contracts supplies replacement dates unless the parties agree their own.

In the NEC4 subcontract itself

The standard timetable has the main contractor certify within two weeks of each assessment date and pay within four, unless the Subcontract Data says otherwise. Nothing in the core clauses ties your money to what the Client has paid. A pay-when-paid clause would have to be a Z clause (an additional condition), so check yours. Many main contractors line subcontract dates up with their own to protect cash flow. That is sensible provided it never becomes a condition of payment.

What to record

  • Assessment date, due date and final date for payment.
  • The certificate and your application.
  • Whether a pay less notice came in, and when.
  • Every message about timing, especially any "when the Client pays" email.

What not to do

  • Do not accept "it is in your order" without asking which clause is relied on. A term cannot override the Act.
  • Do not walk off site without the written notice and advice.
  • Do not accept "the Client rejected your work" in place of a valid, timely pay less notice.

When to get help

If anyone claims insolvency, ask for proof and take legal advice immediately. It is the one exception, and the position can shift within days. Bring in a commercial manager before you adjudicate or suspend.

Example

A fictional ground-works subcontractor is owed £31,000 on an assessment date of 5 June. Money is due 19 June and the final date is 3 July. No pay less notice appears by 26 June. On 8 July the main contractor writes that it will pay once its Client does. The subcontractor answers that day citing section 113, asks for payment with interest, and says it will consider adjudication or suspension.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?