Subcontractor asked to do extra work with no written instruction
What to do as an NEC subcontractor when the main contractor asks for extra work without a written instruction, and how to protect your payment and time.
On this page
The site manager has asked you to do work that is not in your subcontract. Nothing is in writing, they want it done today, and you are worried about being paid for it or being told it was your own choice.
This guide is written for the Subcontractor. If you are the main contractor, the same facts matter to you because you may have a compensation event on the main contract, and your own records need to match.
The short answer
Do not simply start the work and hope. Put the request in writing to the Contractor as soon as you can, saying what you were asked to do, by whom and when, and that you consider it a change to your subcontract. A spoken request still counts for something under NEC, but only if you can prove it and notify within the period in your own subcontract.
What to do, step by step
- Ask what is wanted and why. Check the work is genuinely outside your Subcontract Scope. Compare it against the scope and any drawings or specifications listed in the Subcontract Contract Data.
- Ask for a written instruction. An email or message to the person who asked is enough to start. Say: "Please confirm in writing that you are instructing us to carry out [work]." Keep the reply.
- If you must start before the answer, confirm it yourself. Write the same day: "Further to your verbal request at [time] to carry out [work], we are proceeding on the basis that this is a change to our subcontract and will submit a quotation."
- Check who can instruct you. Under the NEC4 ECS there is no separate Project Manager: the Contractor instructs, accepts and assesses, so the instruction has to come from someone with the Contractor's authority. Find out who is named in your Contract Data. An instruction from the Client's team, or from another trade, may not bind the Contractor.
- Notify a compensation event within your own period. Under the unamended NEC4 subcontract (ECS), clause 61.3 gives you seven weeks from becoming aware, not the eight weeks of the main ECC. Do not wait for the instruction to arrive before you notify. Check your Subcontract Data and Z clauses, because the period can be amended. See time bars for subcontractors.
- Give an early warning if the extra work affects your programme or other work. See noticed a problem, do I give early warning.
- Submit your quotation for the change in price and any delay to your dates, with a revised programme if the work alters your plan. Under the unamended NEC4 ECS you have two weeks to quote once the Contractor instructs you to, and the Contractor has four weeks to reply.
- Keep working to the programme while the quotation is assessed, unless the Contractor tells you otherwise.
What to record
- Who asked, when, where and in what words, with the names of anyone else who heard.
- Photos of the work area before you start and as work progresses.
- Daily labour, plant and materials spent specifically on the extra work.
- Any drawings, sketches or markups you were given.
- Delivery notes and timesheets coded to the extra work.
- Your programme before and after the change.
See keeping records under NEC.
What not to do
- Do not do large extra work on a verbal request with no follow-up.
- Do not assume the Contractor "knows" and will sort it out at the end of the job.
- Do not wait until the final account to raise it.
- Do not rely on a request from someone with no authority under your subcontract, such as a site agent, the Client's team or another trade.
- Do not mix extra and original work in your time sheets.
When to get help
Speak to your commercial manager as soon as the value is more than a trivial amount, or if you are told the work is "within your scope" and you disagree. Get a planner if the extra work moves your Completion Date or Key Dates. If you are told you will not be paid, or the Contractor says there is no instruction and no entitlement, take legal advice before the dispute hardens.
Example
A pipe subcontractor is told by the Contractor's site manager to lay an extra 40 metres of duct in a different trench. Nothing is in writing. The same afternoon the Subcontractor emails the site manager, copies the Contractor's commercial manager, and confirms the instruction and its intention to quote. It starts work, logs labour daily, and submits a quotation within the period in its subcontract. Because the request is on record, the Contractor cannot later say the Subcontractor chose to do the work.
Related guides
- Verbal instruction to do extra work
- Compensation events in plain English
- CE quotation template and guide
- NEC subcontracts explained
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
