Told on site to do extra work, nothing in writing: what to do under NEC
A Project Manager or Client's rep verbally asked for extra work. Here is how to protect your position and notify a compensation event.
On this page
You are on site, someone from the Client's side says "while you're here, can you also do this?", and you start. Nothing is written down. Weeks later the work is questioned or nobody wants to pay for it. This guide is written from the Contractor's side; the same logic applies to a Subcontractor working to the Contractor.
The short answer
Get the instruction into the contract's communication system today, in writing, and notify a compensation event if the extra work changes the Scope. Under NEC, communications have to be made in the form the contract requires, so a verbal instruction on its own is weak evidence. The eight-week notification clock under clause 61.3 starts when you become aware of the event, not when someone confirms it.
What to do, step by step
- Stop and identify who gave the instruction. Was it the Project Manager, a delegate you have been told about, the Supervisor, or someone else? The power to change the Scope sits with the Project Manager (14.3) and can be delegated only to someone the Contractor has been notified of (14.2). The Supervisor's powers are about tests and Defects, and the Contractor's duty to obey runs to the Project Manager and Supervisor (27.3). A Client representative, however senior, cannot change the Scope unless delegated and notified. Check who has authority before you spend money.
- Decide whether to carry on. If the work is safe, small and clearly wanted, you may continue. If it is large, risky or unclear, pause and ask for a written instruction first. Doing so is not obstruction.
- Confirm it in writing straight away. Send a short message through the contract's communication system (check the clause on communications, clause 13, and your Contract Data for the system and form). State who said what, when, where, and what you understood. Ask the Project Manager to correct you if you have it wrong.
- Ask the Project Manager to instruct it formally if the person who spoke to you was not the Project Manager. If the Project Manager refuses and the work is already done, ask whether it is being accepted as it stands or you are being told to reverse it. Either answer tells you where you stand.
- Notify the compensation event. If the instruction changes the Scope (Works Information in NEC3), notify it under clause 61.3, within eight weeks of becoming aware (seven under the NEC4 subcontract). Do not wait for a reply to your confirmation. The exemption from the eight weeks covers only instructions from the Project Manager or Supervisor, so do not assume it protects you for an instruction from the Client's side. If the Project Manager did give the instruction, the time limit does not bite in the usual way and the Project Manager should have notified the event itself (61.1).
- Give an early warning if the extra work will affect other work, programme, or cost beyond the obvious.
- Prepare the quotation when the Project Manager asks for one, including the programme effect. See how to prepare a CE quotation.
What to record
- Date, time and place of the conversation.
- Who gave the instruction, who was present, and their role.
- The exact words used as best you can recall them.
- What you were doing at the time and what the extra work is.
- Photographs of the work before, during and after.
- Labour, plant and materials used on the extra work, from the start. Keep these separate from the base work.
- Any follow-up conversation or reply.
What not to do
- Do not do large extra work on a verbal instruction and hope to sort the paperwork out later.
- Do not assume a verbal instruction is a valid instruction under the contract. An instruction from the Project Manager should be in recordable form (13.1), and one from the Client's side is not an instruction at all unless the Project Manager has delegated that action to them and told you.
- Do not wait for the Project Manager to notify the event for you.
- Do not bury the confirmation in a long email on another subject.
- Do not argue the point on site. State that you will confirm it in writing and do so.
- Do not mix extra-work time and cost into your normal timesheets.
When to get help
Bring in your commercial manager when the extra work is more than minor, when the person who instructed you may not have had authority, when the Project Manager denies the instruction, or when the eight weeks is close. Ask a CPMP planner to check the programme effect if the extra work touches the critical path. Take legal advice if the work is now disputed.
Example
A Contractor is laying a pipe. A Client representative asks it to extend the trench 15 metres to pick up another connection. The Contractor agrees and finishes the day. That evening, the site manager sends a message through the communication system confirming the request and asking the Project Manager to instruct formally. The commercial manager notifies a compensation event the next morning and begins a separate cost record. The Project Manager later accepts the instruction and asks for a quotation.
Related guides
- Compensation events in plain English
- Missed the eight-week deadline
- Instruction conflicts with the Scope
- Keeping records under NEC
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
