Someone told you to change the work out loud: can you start?

What to do when the Project Manager gives a verbal instruction under NEC: get it in writing, protect your compensation event, handle urgent safety work.

Communications and recordsScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When the position differs
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

On a site walk the Project Manager said "move that door" and walked on. Nothing has arrived in writing, and the gang wants to carry on. Starting changed work on a conversation alone is risky under NEC.

The short answer

Do not rely on a spoken instruction. Clause 13.1 wants contract communications in a form that can be read, copied and kept, so changed work done on talk alone may earn you nothing. The Project Manager is the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day, and a compensation event is the contract's term for something that can change your price or dates. Write down what was said, email it the same day, ask for a written instruction, and notify the event to protect your position.

What to do, step by step

  1. Jot down the speaker, time, place and the precise change.
  2. Email the Project Manager that afternoon. Say what you understood, and request a written instruction before any work begins.
  3. Pause the affected work if possible. If pausing is dangerous or expensive, tell them why, explain your interim plan, and set a time by which you need an answer.
  4. Notify a compensation event under 61.3. Some events skip the time bar when an instruction caused them, but a chat may not count as one, so do not count on that. Eight weeks run from when you became aware; notify well inside them.
  5. Ring-fence the cost of this change. Work finished before the dividing date is assessed on actual Defined Cost, meaning what the labour, plant and materials really cost you, so keep those timesheets and invoices apart.

What to record

  • The notes of what was said and who was present.
  • Your confirming email and any reply.
  • Drawing or Scope references the change departs from.
  • Dates and times the work started or was held.
  • Timesheets, plant logs and invoices coded to this change.

What not to do

  • Do not assume silence after your email makes the instruction valid. NEC has no deemed-confirmation rule. Your email is good evidence, but it is only a request for an instruction.
  • Do not build first and sort the paperwork later. With no instruction changing the Scope, the Project Manager can say it is not a listed event, and departing from the Scope may be treated as a Defect you fix at your cost.
  • Do not rely on memory. People move on and recollections differ.

When the position differs

  • Urgent safety. Clause 27.4 points you to the safety rules in the Scope. If someone could be hurt, nobody waits for an email. Deal with the danger, then document it that day.
  • A stop instruction. Being told to stop is usually something to obey, then ask to have confirmed straight away. Once given, it is an event under 60.1(4).
  • A named communication system. Where the Scope names a system, NEC4 13.2 says a communication takes effect through that system, so an ordinary email may not be enough.

When to get help

Speak to your commercial manager if the answer comes back that no change was intended, or if the work is already built. Better still, agree a quick route when the job starts, perhaps a phone-based form issued the same day.

Example

A pumping station refurbishment. The Project Manager says on site that a plant room door should move one bay east. The contractor emails that afternoon: "Please confirm this by instruction. We reach this wall on Thursday and need your answer by Wednesday midday." The contractor also notifies the event. The instruction follows on Wednesday, and the blockwork goes up once.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?