Mutual trust and co-operation on NEC: turning clause 10 into daily habits

What clause 10 asks of you in practice, what it does not do for you, and how to build five or six specific behaviours into an NEC job.

Tendering and starting a contract3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. What clause 10 will not do
  3. Behaviours to aim for
  4. Example: a bridge-bearing replacement
  5. Building it in
  6. Related guides

Clause 10 of NEC says the Parties, and anyone acting for them, must do what the contract says and act in a spirit of mutual trust and co-operation. On site that only means something once it becomes concrete habits: warning early, answering on time, sharing information and raising disagreement quickly. NEC3 puts both duties in 10.1. NEC4 splits them into 10.1 and 10.2.

In plain English

Trust under NEC is not being friendly. It is doing what the contract says, on time, and being open about it. Disagreeing politely with reasons is part of it.

What clause 10 will not do

  • Stop the clocks. A good relationship does not pause the eight weeks in 61.3.
  • Excuse a missed deadline. Goodwill may help, but it is not a right you can count on.
  • Require you to agree. Saying no, with reasons and in time, fits the clause. A Project Manager who properly rejects a weak quotation is doing the job.
  • Rewrite the deal. How far the clause adds to the specific terms is a legal question. If you may need to rely on it in a dispute, take advice.

Behaviours to aim for

  1. Warn early. Raise a problem as soon as you know of it, before you have the answer (15.1). Waiting to see if it disappears is the opposite.
  2. Answer within the period. Reply in time, or ask for longer before time runs out (13.3, 13.5). Silence as a tactic breaks the spirit.
  3. Say why. If you reject something, explain what is wrong and what would fix it (13.4). A bare "not accepted" does not help.
  4. Show your working on cost. A quotation should have its build-up, and an assessment should be explained. A lump sum with nothing behind it, or an unexplained cut, erodes trust.
  5. Look for options together. Discuss alternatives for an event before pricing them (62.1), and settle blame later.
  6. Treat notices as routine. Compensation events are the normal way to handle change, not a hostile act.
  7. Escalate disagreement quickly. Tell the other side, and raise it with the right level, rather than saving it for the final account.

Example: a bridge-bearing replacement

The Contractor finds that the pier seating is more damaged than described, so its planned lifting method will not work.

Version one. It sends a lengthy letter quoting 60.1(12). The Project Manager rejects it that day, saying the risk is the Contractor's. Both sides take advice and six weeks pass with the job at a standstill.

Version two. It issues an early warning and a notification the same day. The Project Manager convenes an early warning meeting and the Client's engineer attends. They examine the survey data and settle on two feasible methods. The Project Manager gives a view on 60.1(12), with reasons, within a week. If it is an event, alternative quotations can be instructed (62.1). If not, the Contractor still has that view in time to refer the point onward, and both sides have chosen the faster method. The argument about payment does not hold up the work.

Nobody gave anything away in version two. They simply used the contract's own steps promptly.

Building it in

  • Agree a short list at kick-off. About five behaviours, each specific enough to test. See running a kick-off meeting.
  • Measure both sides. Report reply times, the age of open compensation events and warnings raised, jointly.
  • Name a senior pair. If something stalls for a week, they should hear informally before it becomes a formal matter.
  • Respect the Project Manager's independence. A Client that steers decisions undermines trust. Within the contract, the two should agree how they work together.
  • Review monthly. Spend ten minutes asking what each side could do differently.
  • Consider X12 or X20 if you want formal partnering or incentives. They add to the behaviours, never replace them.

Do not use "the spirit of the contract" to excuse ignoring its words.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?