You underpriced an NEC job: what you can and cannot change

Priced a job too low under NEC? Why it is not a compensation event, how each main Option treats the error, and what you can do this week.

Tendering and starting a contractScenario4 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. How each main Option treats a wrong price
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

You have signed, the job is under way, and you now realise the price is too low. The question is whether the contract lets you reopen it.

The short answer

No. A pricing mistake of your own is not a compensation event, and nothing in the core clauses lets you reopen the Prices because the tender was wrong. Once the contract is signed, changing it needs both Parties to agree, confirm it in writing and sign it (12.3 in the NEC4 ECC), and the Client has no duty to do so. How much it hurts depends on your main Option and on whether the problem is really a pricing error or a mistake in the documents.

What to do, step by step

  1. Size the problem and find its cause. An arithmetic slip, a wrong method assumption, a missed item and a market price rise each lead somewhere different.
  2. Look for real events hiding in it. Pricing shortfalls are often tangled up with genuine compensation events nobody has notified. The clock on those keeps running while you investigate, so note now the eight weeks (seven under the NEC4 ECS) from when you became aware.
  3. Consider an early warning about cost. The NEC4 ECC (15.1) allows a warning about something that could raise your own total cost, even if the Prices would not change. It puts the problem on the table without blaming anybody.
  4. Look for a cheaper way to build. Clause 16 lets you propose a Scope change that reduces what the Client pays. Under Options C and D the saving flows through the share calculation. Under A and B you can negotiate how to split it.
  5. Check the documents, not just the numbers. See the exceptions below.
  6. Update your cash flow and brief your board. Do not claw the gap back through inflated quotations: they are assessed on forecast Defined Cost, so it fails and damages trust.

How each main Option treats a wrong price

  • Option A (activity schedule): your lump sum for each activity stays. You carry the whole shortfall.
  • Option B (Bill of Quantities): the rate stays, so a low rate times a growing quantity gets worse. Clause 60.4 can reprice, but only in narrow circumstances.
  • Options C and D (target cost): a low target makes it more likely you pay a share of any overrun. During the job you are still paid Defined Cost and Fee.
  • Option E (cost reimbursable): you are paid Defined Cost plus Fee, so a pricing error mainly upsets the Client's forecast.

What to record

  • The original build-up of the price and the tender queries and answers.
  • The documents you priced from, with revisions.
  • Dates when each part of the problem first became known.
  • Actual costs against priced figures, item by item.

What not to do

  • Do not treat the shortfall as a compensation event just to get it in front of the Project Manager.
  • Do not pad later quotations, or sit on genuine events while you debate pricing.
  • Do not assume the Client will agree to a price change. If it does, make sure it is a signed change under 12.3 and not a verbal comfort.

When to get help

Tell your commercial director early. Get a lawyer quickly if you think the Client misled you, or if the error was spotted before the contract was accepted, since the position then differs. A planner can help find method savings.

Some problems are not really pricing risk:

  • Under Options B and D, a Bill that misdescribes work or breaks the stated measurement method, or is ambiguous, is corrected by the Project Manager as a compensation event (60.6). A badly chosen rate does not qualify.
  • A quantity that grows beyond a stated threshold can trigger repricing under 60.4. Delay from quantity differences is dealt with in 60.5.
  • If the Scope contradicts itself and you priced one reading, that is a Scope ambiguity (17.1), not a pricing error.

Example

An Option B kerbing job, invented figures. Kerb laying was priced at £40 a metre but costs £55. An instruction adds 300 metres. The extra is assessed from forecast cost plus Fee, near £55 plus Fee, not £40. The shortfall on the original quantity stays with you, but does not spread to the new work.

Expect the Client to say the Prices stand, which is right, and to worry about whether you can finish. Bring a plan showing you can.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?