Defined Cost, Fee and Disallowed Cost explained
Defined Cost, Fee and Disallowed Cost in plain English for NEC Options C to F: what they mean, how they link, and how to avoid cost being disallowed.
On this page
On cost-based NEC contracts you are paid for what the work costs, plus a margin, rather than for a fixed price. Three defined terms drive that: Defined Cost, Fee and Disallowed Cost. This guide explains them in plain English for Options C and D (target contracts), E (cost reimbursable) and F (management contract). Always check the exact definitions in your contract, because Z clauses often change them.
The three terms
Defined Cost is the cost of the things the contract lists as payable: in general terms people, Equipment, Plant and Materials, subcontractors, and certain charges. The schedule of cost components is a closed list: anything you spend outside it is treated as covered by the Fee, and what is inside it is limited to the rates in the Contract Data or to market or competitively tendered prices, after recoverable discounts, rebates and taxes. So it is not the same as your actual cost.
Fee is the Contractor's margin for overheads and profit, and for any cost that has no component in the schedule. It is calculated by applying the fee percentage in the Contract Data to the Defined Cost. NEC4 ECC has one fee percentage; NEC3 ECC has two, a direct fee percentage and a subcontracted fee percentage. Disallowed Cost is removed before the Fee is worked out, so you lose the Fee on it too.
Disallowed Cost is cost the Contractor has really spent but cannot recover. The list is short and specific, and anything not on it stays in. The main items are: cost not justified by the accounts and records; payments to a Subcontractor or supplier beyond what its contract required; cost incurred only because a Scope procedure was not followed or a required early warning was not given; the whole cost of correcting Defects after Completion; the cost of correcting Defects caused by not following a constraint in the Scope; Plant and Materials not used, beyond reasonable wastage; resources left unused beyond reasonable availability, or kept after a request to remove them; and the cost of preparing for and conducting an adjudication or tribunal between the Parties. NEC4 adds cost incurred only because the Project Manager was not told of an adjudication or tribunal with a Subcontractor or supplier. Normal rework of Defects before Completion is not on the list.
Check the exact list of Disallowed Cost in your contract. Do not rely on a summary.
How they fit into payment
Payment under clause 50 and clause 51 on a cost-based Option takes the Defined Cost paid to date plus the Defined Cost the Project Manager forecasts will have been paid by the next assessment date, removes Disallowed Cost, and adds the Fee. It is a forecast, not a measure of progress. See how payment works under NEC.
How Options differ
| Option | Basis | What you carry |
|---|---|---|
| C | Target price with activity schedule | The Price for Work Done to Date is Defined Cost plus Fee. At the end, overspend or underspend against the target is shared by the share percentages in the Contract Data. |
| D | Target price with bill of quantities | The same mechanism as C, with a bill of quantities. |
| E | Cost reimbursable | You are paid Defined Cost plus Fee. No target, no pain or gain share. |
| F | Management contract | The Contractor manages Subcontractors and is paid what is due to them, plus the Contract Data prices for any work it does itself, less Disallowed Cost, plus the Fee. |
On Options C and D, every pound that becomes Disallowed Cost is a pound that does not reach you, and the target moves only when compensation events are implemented. The quality of your compensation event record therefore matters as much as your cost record.
Records the Project Manager can inspect
Cost-based Options expect you to keep and show accounts and records. Keep:
- timesheets and payroll records tied to the Working Areas and activities,
- Equipment and Plant hire records, with start and end dates,
- orders, delivery notes and invoices for Materials,
- subcontractor applications, certificates and payments,
- records showing which cost relates to a compensation event.
See keeping records under NEC.
Avoiding Disallowed Cost
- Read the list of Disallowed Cost in your contract at the start.
- Code costs to activities and compensation events as you incur them, not at month end.
- Track Defect correction separately. Correcting a Defect after Completion, or one caused by breaking a constraint in the Scope, is Disallowed Cost. See defects under NEC.
- Keep the programme and the cost forecast consistent.
- Where unsure whether something is Defined Cost, ask the Project Manager in writing before you incur it.
Common mistakes
- Treating the Fee as a flat sum rather than a percentage of Defined Cost.
- Charging time spent on matters the contract excludes.
- Failing to link Defined Cost to a compensation event, so the target never moves.
- Assuming payment on a cost-based Option means the Project Manager cannot query cost.
Related guides
- The Project Manager assessed my payment much lower than I expected
- Compensation events in plain English
- Can I be paid for materials and Plant delivered to site or stored off site?
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
