The Project Manager assessed my payment too low

What to do when the Project Manager's assessment is far below your expectation: compare, query in writing, evidence the gap and escalate under NEC.

Payment and costScenario4 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Common causes of a low assessment
  4. What to record
  5. What not to do
  6. When to get help
  7. Example
  8. Related guides

The certificate has arrived and the figure is much lower than your own. This guide is written for a Contractor assessed by the Project Manager. A Subcontractor assessed by the Contractor can follow the same steps, using the subcontract's terms.

The short answer

Do not simply accept the certificate, and do not simply complain. Work out exactly where your figure and theirs differ, line by line, then query the difference in writing promptly. Under clause 50 the Project Manager assesses the amount due at each assessment date and does not have to adopt your figure, but the certificate has to show how the amount was assessed (NEC4 51.1, NEC3 50.4). A wrong assessment is corrected in a later certificate under clause 50.6, and interest can follow on the correcting amount in some cases (51.3), so the next assessment is an opportunity to correct an error, provided you have the evidence ready.

What to do, step by step

  1. Get the assessment in detail. If the certificate is a single sum, ask in writing for the breakdown. Without it you cannot see what was excluded.
  2. Compare line by line. Put your application and their assessment side by side. Group the differences: progress, compensation events, materials, Defined Cost, deductions.
  3. Identify the cause of each gap. Common causes are in the table below.
  4. Write to the Project Manager. Use clause 13 communications. Set out each disputed item, your figure, your evidence, and ask for reassessment at the next assessment date or sooner if the contract allows.
  5. Check the payment is made on what was certified. The certified sum is still due within three weeks of the assessment date, unless your Contract Data gives another period (clause 51.2). Do not treat a dispute as a reason to delay invoicing or chasing.
  6. Escalate if the answer is unreasonable. Raise it with the commercial lead. Consider the dispute resolution Option in your contract (W1 or W2, or W3 in NEC4) if the gap is not resolved. Under W2, where the Construction Act applies, adjudication can start at any time; under W1 a four-week limit runs from when you become aware of the matter, so write down your objection the same week. See adjudication under NEC.
  7. Take legal advice about notices and deadlines under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (as amended). Time limits matter.

Common causes of a low assessment

Cause What to check
Application late (NEC4) An application must go in before the assessment date. If it did not, the amount due is the lesser of the Project Manager's own assessment and the amount due at the previous date (clause 50.4). It can fall but cannot rise, and the missing value returns at the next assessment.
Progress not accepted Option A pays only completed activities, with no percentage complete, and an activity with a notified Defect that holds up following work is not complete. Check your claimed progress against the Activity Schedule and your evidence.
Compensation events not included Have quotations been submitted, and implemented? See compensation events in plain English.
First programme not submitted If the Contract Data names no programme, a quarter of the Price for Work Done to Date is held back until you submit a first programme showing the required information (NEC4 50.5, NEC3 50.3). It depends on submission, not acceptance. See Clause 31 programme checklist.
Defined Cost reduced Was cost treated as Disallowed Cost, or the forecast to the next assessment date cut? Ask which part of the definition applies. See Defined Cost, Fee and Disallowed Cost.
Materials excluded Check the provisions on Plant and Materials. See paid for materials on site and off site.
Deductions Which clause is relied on, and has the notice been given that the clause needs?

What to record

  • Your application, with the date submitted and supporting progress records.
  • The certificate and any explanation received.
  • Your line-by-line comparison.
  • Photographs, delivery notes, site diaries and measurement records for disputed work.
  • All correspondence on the difference, dated.

What not to do

  • Do not ignore the certificate until the next application.
  • Do not send a one-line email saying "we disagree". Give figures.
  • Do not exaggerate your figure. An inflated number weakens a sound case.
  • Do not stop work because of a short payment without legal advice.

When to get help

If the gap is more than a few per cent, or turns on programme and delay, bring in a commercial manager and a planner. If the Project Manager has acted outside the contract or the sum is large, take legal advice before you escalate.

Example

A Contractor claims 200,000 pounds and is certified at 150,000 pounds. The breakdown shows 30,000 pounds removed for progress on one activity and 20,000 pounds for two compensation events not yet implemented. The Contractor supplies dated progress photographs for the first and chases the quotations for the second, in a single letter with both items.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?