NEC Option A or Option C: who carries your cost overrun?
Compare NEC Option A (lump sums) with Option C (target cost) from the contractor's side, with a side-by-side table and a worked overrun.
Under Option A you carry the whole cost overrun, and you keep the whole saving. Under Option C you are reimbursed your costs and the overrun or saving is split with the Client according to the share percentages. The two look alike on paper because both use an activity schedule, which is a list of work activities with prices. The difference is what the schedule does: in Option A it is what you get paid, and in Option C it only sets the target.
Side by side (NEC4 ECC)
| Option A | Option C | |
|---|---|---|
| How you are paid each month | Lump sums for activities finished | Forecast cost plus your Fee |
| Job of the activity schedule | Decides what you are paid | Sets the target for the share |
| Overrun | Yours | Shared as the Contract Data says |
| Saving | Yours | Shared as the Contract Data says |
| Records open to the Client | Not needed for payment | Required |
| Disallowed cost | Does not arise | Applies |
| Cost basis for compensation events | Shorter schedule with people rates | Full schedule of cost components |
| Forecasts of total cost | Not required | Required at the interval in the Contract Data |
| Your idea accepted to change the Client's Scope | Prices drop by the percentage in the Contract Data (63.12) | Prices stay; the saving goes through the share (63.13) |
| Cash flow | Lumpy, follows finished work | Smoother, follows spend |
| Client effort | Lower | Higher, because cost is reviewed as well as progress |
One overrun, two outcomes
Invented figures: a bridge-bearing replacement tendered at £3,000,000, no compensation events, and an equal Fee in both cases. Under Option C you carry a flat 50%.
- Your cost lands at £3,300,000. Option A: you receive £3,000,000 and are £300,000 worse off. Option C: the Client pays £3,150,000 and you are £150,000 worse off.
- Your cost lands at £2,800,000. Option A: you receive £3,000,000 and are £200,000 better off. Option C: the Client pays £2,900,000 and you are £100,000 better off.
In reality the tender price would differ too. Whoever takes the risk under Option A usually prices an allowance for it, and the Client pays for that allowance whether or not the risk happens.
Which suits you
Option A tends to suit you when:
- the Scope is settled and unlikely to move,
- you know the work and can price it with confidence,
- you want to keep any saving you can find, and
- you do not want the Client's team going through your costs.
Option C tends to suit you when:
- the work has real unknowns that would force a heavy lump-sum allowance,
- your own ideas could change the design or the cost,
- you are comfortable with open records and forecasting, and
- you want to be involved early.
Myths
- "Option A is cheaper for the Client." Not always. The risk allowance is in the price and compensation events are still paid.
- "Option C needs a vague Scope." It needs one firm enough to set a target. A thin Scope produces constant target arguments.
- "You cannot lose on Option C." You can: the share of the excess comes off what you receive and can wipe out your Fee. See pain and gain share.
- "Compensation events work the same in both." They are assessed on forecast effects in both, but under Option A the result changes your payment and under Option C it changes only the target.
Related guides
- NEC Option A: priced contract with activity schedule
- NEC Option C: target contract with activity schedule
- How to choose an NEC main Option
- Risk allocation by main Option
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
