NEC Option B: paid by measurement against a Bill of Quantities

How NEC Option B pays rates times measured quantities, when a quantity change becomes a compensation event, and the mistakes to avoid.

NEC Options and contract types3 min read

On this page
  1. How payment works
  2. When does a quantity change give you a compensation event?
  3. Pricing other compensation events
  4. When it suits you
  5. Common mistakes
  6. Related guides

On an Option B contract you price every line of a Bill of Quantities, and you are paid your rates multiplied by the quantities you actually complete. If your rates are too low, that hurts you. If the quantities in the Bill turn out wrong, the Client carries it. The guide uses NEC4 ECC as its base and flags NEC3 where it differs.

How payment works

  • The Bill is normally prepared for you to price, using the method of measurement named in Contract Data.
  • Each payment counts completed quantity times rate for each item, plus the completed share of any lump sum item.
  • Unlike Option A, a lump sum item can be paid in part while unfinished. Preliminaries are commonly billed like that.
  • Work counts as complete unless a notified defect would delay later work once corrected.
  • Text in the Bill is neither Scope nor Site Information (56.1), so a Bill description cannot add to or reduce your duties.

When does a quantity change give you a compensation event?

Ordinarily, extra or reduced work of the same kind is simply measured and paid at the rate you tendered. Four clauses cover the exceptions:

  • 60.4: the rate itself is wrong. The final quantity departs from the Bill for a reason other than a Scope change, and your cost per unit shifts as a result. The item must also be big enough: rate times final quantity above 0.5% of the total Prices at the Contract Date. If unit cost falls, the rate falls.
  • 60.5: delay. A quantity difference holds up Completion or a Key Date.
  • 60.6: a mistake in the Bill. The Project Manager instructs a correction where the Bill departs from the method of measurement or is ambiguous or inconsistent. This can reduce the Prices as well as raise them.
  • 60.7: the Bill and another document disagree. When the clash is corrected, you are treated as having assumed the Bill was right.

Example, with invented figures: on a £2,000,000 job the 0.5% threshold is £10,000. A Bill item for 300 cubic metres of rock excavation at £60 turns out to need 900. At final quantity it is worth £54,000, well above the threshold, so you can notify a new rate provided the extra volume changes your cost per cubic metre. A small £6,000 item falls below the line for 60.4, though 60.5 may still help if it causes delay.

Pricing other compensation events

Under 63.15 the changed Prices appear as alterations to the Bill. For unfinished work with an existing item, you get a new rate, quantity or lump sum. With no existing item, it is a new item built to the method of measurement unless both sides agree otherwise. For finished work, it is a new lump sum item.

The assessment itself still uses the Short Schedule of Cost Components and People Rates. Bill rates do not price a compensation event, which surprises people from JCT or ICC backgrounds.

When it suits you

  • The design is measurable but quantities might move, as in earthworks or some drainage.
  • A standard method of measurement suits the work.
  • You are content for the final price to move with quantities.

It suits contractor-designed work badly, because there is nothing to measure until a design exists.

Common mistakes

  1. Treating the Bill total as a promise. It estimates the final account.
  2. Assuming any quantity change reprices the rate. Only the 60.4 tests do that.
  3. Leaving the method of measurement vague, then arguing about mistakes under 60.6.
  4. Using NEC3 numbers on an NEC4 job. In NEC3 the Bill rule is 55.1 and the assessment form is B63.13, while NEC4 brings in People Rates and a value engineering percentage.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?