New regulations mean extra work: who pays under NEC?

A change in law after the Contract Date: when Option X2 makes it the Client's cost, when it stays with you, and how to notify.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

A new law or regulation has come into force part way through the job, and it makes you do something extra or differently. Who bears the cost depends mainly on one item in your contract.

The short answer

Look in your Contract Data for Option X2 (the secondary Option for changes in law). With X2 in the contract, a change in the law of the country where the Site is, made after the Contract Date, counts as a compensation event and the Client pays. With no X2, you normally bear the cost, with one exception: a rule that makes the Client's own Scope unworkable. The clause numbering below is NEC4 ECC, and X2.1 is numbered the same in NEC3.

What to do, step by step

  1. Give an early warning at once. Do it whenever the change might add cost or push out Completion (clause 15.1, or 16.1 in NEC3).
  2. Check the Contract Data for X2 and note the Contract Date.
  3. Start the clock. You have eight weeks from the day you become aware of the event (clause 61.3). Nobody at the Client's end instructs a change in law, so the exemption for instructions will not rescue a late notice. Write down the date you first knew.
  4. Get the source document. Pin down the actual legislation, the day it commenced and any transitional arrangements. A summary from a trade body will not do.
  5. Separate the effect. List what must change on site, the cost and time that follow, and what you would have done anyway.

What to record

  • The instrument itself, with the date it came into force
  • Your tender and programme basis, to show the difference
  • The date you became aware
  • Quotation workings that price only the extra
  • Early warnings and replies

What not to do

  • Do not rely on regulator guidance, a trade standard or a Client policy as though it were law. The clause talks about changes in the law.
  • Do not claim for laws made before the Contract Date. These should have been dealt with before signing, so look for a Z clause instead.
  • Do not use X2 for a change in another country's law that raises import prices. X2 looks only at the Site's country, though Option X1 may help separately.
  • Do not forget the downside. If the change makes things cheaper, the same clause reduces the Prices.
Situation Likely position
X2 selected, and the law of the Site's country moved after the Contract Date Client pays
No X2, but the Client's Scope can no longer lawfully be built The Scope is changed by instruction, normally an event
No X2, and only your own design is hit Generally you
No X2, and only your working methods or costs are hit Generally you, unless some other event applies

When to get help

Arguments gather at the edges: regulator guidance you are expected to follow, legislation made before the Contract Date but only in force afterwards, or a Client standard tightened in the name of the new law. Take advice if a lot depends on whether something counts as law. Anything the Client asks for beyond what the law demands is a Scope change and needs an instruction.

On a subcontract the Subcontract Date applies. A law made between the main contract and subcontract dates could therefore be covered at one level only. In the NEC4 term service contract the law of the place of the Affected Property is the test.

Example

A pumping station refit on Option A with X2 selected. A new rule on fuel storage bunding comes into force after the Contract Date and requires larger bunds for the standby generator. You warn on the day you read it, notify within weeks, and price only the difference between the bund you planned and the one now required, plus the extra days. The Client says you knew it was coming, but X2 looks at dates, not foresight.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?