How secondary Options are chosen on an NEC4 contract, and what they mean for you

A contractor's view of NEC4 secondary Options: which questions drive the choice, which combinations clash, and what each Option can cost your business.

NEC Options and contract types3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. Questions a Client should ask, and what you will see
  3. Combinations that do not work
  4. What each group costs you
  5. Sample pairings, to recognise a pattern
  6. What people get wrong
  7. A sensible order of work if you are involved at tender
  8. Related guides

Secondary Options are the add-on blocks of an NEC4 contract, such as delay damages, price adjustment or bonds. The Client picks them before tender, but you price them, so you need to know why each one is there and what it asks of you. Every Option either moves a risk or adds a process, and neither comes free.

This guide uses NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract (ECC) numbering. Other forms and editions number things differently, so check yours.

In plain English

The main Option (A to F) sets how you are paid. Secondary Options sit on top and deal with specific risks: late finish, inflation, third-party rights, security. Each one you spot in the Contract Data, the part of the contract where the project-specific entries live, is a cost or a duty you should price.

Questions a Client should ask, and what you will see

If the answer is yes Option you may find
Does the UK Construction Act apply to the work? W2 and Y(UK)2 (W1 if not)
Could inflation hit costs badly? X1, with main Options A to D only
Is the contractor part of a group whose guarantee is doubtful? X4 or X13
Does the Client need sections early? X5
Does a late finish cost the Client real money? X7
Is finishing early worth money to the Client? X6
Will you design, with an outcome-based Scope? X15 (and read X9)
Is BIM involved? X10
Will funders or tenants want direct rights? X8 or Y(UK)3
May the Client change its plans before Completion? X11

Combinations that do not work

  • X12 and X20 are not used together.
  • X1 applies only with main Options A to D.
  • X3 applies only with A and B.
  • X16 is not used with Option F.
  • X22 applies only with C and E.
  • W1, W2 and W3 are alternatives: exactly one is needed.
  • X7 alongside X5 or X6 is fine, and often priced per section.

If you spot a clash in a tender document, query it before you price.

What each group costs you

  1. Security (X4, X13, X16): guarantee and bond premiums, cash tied up, and pressure on your bonding capacity.
  2. Incentives (X6, X20): upside for you, but only if you understand the measurement and have the records.
  3. Liability (X15, X18): the Client pays less at tender but you hold more risk, so allow for it.
  4. Process (X10, X12, X22): someone in your team has to run them. An Option nobody operates still binds you.

Sample pairings, to recognise a pattern

These are common shapes, not recommendations. A small Option A building job might carry W2, Y(UK)2, X7 and X16. A long Option C infrastructure scheme might add X1, X5, X18 and X15. A job with a funder and tenant might add X8 and Y(UK)3.

What people get wrong

  • Copying the last contract. NEC3 selections do not map cleanly onto NEC4. X19 is the standard example of a number whose meaning changed.
  • Ticking the Option but leaving the data blank. Many Options need entries in the Contract Data or text in the Scope. Blank entries can leave the Option unworkable.
  • Reaching for a Z clause (an extra clause added by the Client) when a secondary Option already does the job. See reading Z clauses.
  • Forgetting the subcontracts. What the main contract selects usually needs a matching decision further down. See back-to-back subcontracts.
  • Choosing Options before the main Option. The main Option decides which are open. Start with choosing a main Option.

A sensible order of work if you are involved at tender

  1. List the top risks and who should own each.
  2. Fix the main Option and the dispute Option.
  3. Write down a reason for every secondary Option.
  4. Draft the matching data and Scope text.
  5. Have a commercial manager read it as a tenderer would.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?