The Client has changed its mind on the design: how you get paid

How a Client change of mind turns into an NEC instruction and compensation event, the proposed-instruction route, and what to do before you act.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

Someone at the Client has said they would rather have a different finish, layout or specification, and you have already ordered materials. The question is how that becomes something you can be paid for.

The short answer

A Client's change of mind has to come to you as a Project Manager's instruction changing the Scope (clause 14.3), and that is a compensation event under clause 60.1(1). The Client never instructs you directly. Until the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract) has instructed in writing, do not act on a remark, a chat or a design review comment. For NEC4 there is also a route where the Client asks for a price before deciding, through a proposed instruction.

What to do, step by step

  1. Ask for an instruction under clause 14.3. A comment in a meeting is not one.
  2. Stop any work that would be wasted once you are instructed, and tell your supply chain.
  3. Record what is already done: orders placed, fabrication, design hours.
  4. Quote within three weeks of being told to, including wasted work and the effect on planned Completion.
  5. Notify the event yourself under clause 61.3 if the Project Manager has not. An event that stems from an instruction should escape the eight-week limit, but send it anyway.
  6. If the Client wants a price first, the Project Manager can instruct a quotation for a proposed instruction (clause 65.1 in NEC4, with the NEC3 route at 61.2 and 62.3). You do not act on it. The quotation takes three weeks under the main contract, two under the NEC4 subcontract, and no reply from the Client means it is not accepted.

Under NEC4, the cost of pricing an option the Client then declines can itself be recovered as a compensation event under clause 60.1(20). NEC3 has no such event.

What to record

  • Who asked for the change, when, and in what form
  • The Scope wording that was in force before
  • Costs already committed or spent on the superseded design
  • The Project Manager's instruction and its date
  • Programme effect, shown against the Accepted Programme

What not to do

  • Do not follow a design review comment without an instruction. If you do, you may have no event.
  • Do not assume every design change is yours to be paid for. It depends on whose design it is:
Whose design changes Likely result
The Client's design in the Scope Compensation event
Your design, because the Client's requirement in the Scope has moved Compensation event
Your design, changed at your request or to meet a Scope the Client already gave Excluded
Client simply prefers something else, but your design meets the Scope Not a Defect. An instruction is needed
  • Do not let a proposed-instruction quotation lapse silently. Ask what the decision date is.

When to get help

If the Client says it is just developing the design, a commercial manager should check whether the Scope already demanded the result. If your quotation is called too high, ask for the reasons in writing before revising. A planner should show how the change disrupts sequence.

Example

A water treatment works on Option C. After the Accepted Programme is in place, the Client wants the chemical store cladding changed from one system to another. The Project Manager issues a proposed instruction with a decision date. You quote £36,000 and ten working days. The Client declines. Your invented pricing cost of £1,500 is assessed as an event under 60.1(20). Had the Client gone ahead, the £36,000 would have raised the total of the Prices and so the target.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?