A test failed on site: who pays for the repeat?

Whether you or the Client pays for a failed NEC test depends on the cause. Learn the clauses, the cost rules by main Option and what to record.

Defects, quality and completionScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. Who carries what
  4. The money differs by main Option
  5. What to record
  6. What not to do
  7. When to get help
  8. Example
  9. Related guides

A test has come back failed and you need to know whether it costs you or the Client.

The short answer

The cause decides it. A genuine Defect (work that does not meet the Scope) means you put it right, the test is run again, and you reimburse what the repeat cost the Client as assessed by the Project Manager. If the work is actually fine and the fault lay with the test, or with the Client failing in its own duties, you may recover your loss through a compensation event. See clauses 41.4 and 41.6 in NEC4 ECC (40.4 and 40.6 in NEC3).

What to do, step by step

  1. Get the result on paper and note the date you learned of it. Your notice clock for any compensation event starts at that awareness: eight weeks (61.3), or seven in the NEC4 subcontract.
  2. Preserve retained samples and calibration certificates, and record the test method and the operator.
  3. Decide whether the work actually fails the Scope. A low reading alone does not make it a Defect.
  4. Give an early warning if Completion or a Key Date could slip.
  5. If it is a Defect, correct it inside the defect correction period and arrange the retest with notice under 41.3.

Who carries what

Cause Result Clause
Work does not meet the Scope You correct and pay the Client's repeat cost 41.4, 41.6
Your design breaks the law or your accepted design Same as above 11.2, 41.4
The Scope's requirement cannot be met, or is wrong Not a Defect; a Project Manager's instruction changing the Scope is an event 60.1(1)
The Supervisor ran the test badly and caused needless delay Compensation event 60.1(11)
The Client left out materials, facilities or samples it promised Compensation event 60.1(16)

The money differs by main Option

What 41.6 captures is the Client's own outlay on the repeat, for example the testing house it uses. Your own cost of correcting and retesting is handled separately.

  • Options A and B: the Prices do not change, so you carry it.
  • Options C, D and E: putting right a Defect after Completion is Disallowed Cost, and so is anything caused by ignoring a constraint in the Scope. Correcting before Completion can stay Defined Cost. The clause 41.6 figure also excludes your own repeat cost (41.7).

What to record

  • The test report, with date, method and tester.
  • Sample and calibration evidence.
  • Independent retest results.
  • Days lost on each affected activity.

What not to do

  • Do not let evidence be discarded while the cause is open.
  • Do not accept a repeat-test charge without a breakdown. It should cover the repeat only, not the Client's whole testing programme.
  • Do not assume the failure is automatically a Defect, or automatically not.

When to get help

Talk to a commercial manager when the argument rests on proving cause. The contract is silent on who must prove what, and in practice better records usually carry the day, so independent retests earn their cost. If you still disagree, refer it under your dispute Option.

Example

A fictional headwall on Option A gets low strength results on three of six cubes. The delivery tickets show the wrong mix, so you demolish and recast at £14,000 of your own money and pay the £900 retest charge that the Project Manager assesses. Now change one fact: cores taken from the same pour pass, and the laboratory admits its curing tank failed. There is no Defect, and you notify an event under 60.1(11) for the three days lost.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?