How tests and inspections work under NEC

What the NEC test and inspection clause covers, the notice you must give, the three compensation events linked to testing and who pays for a repeat test.

Defects, quality and completion3 min read

On this page
  1. The clause at a glance
  2. In plain English
  3. The notice that catches people out
  4. Three compensation events to know
  5. Who pays for a repeat test
  6. Payment tied to a test
  7. Testing before delivery
  8. What to put in the Scope
  9. Example
  10. Related guides

Testing under NEC is short on detail and long on consequences. Clause 41 of the NEC4 ECC (40 in NEC3) covers only the tests and inspections demanded by the Scope (the document setting out what the Contractor must deliver, called Works Information in NEC3) or by law. Warn the other side before testing, share the results afterwards, and if a test exposes a Defect (work that does not meet the Scope), put it right and test again. The practical question is who pays when something fails.

The clause at a glance

Topic NEC4 ECC NEC3 ECC
Only tests the Scope or the law require 41.1 40.1
Materials, facilities and samples as the Scope states 41.2 40.2
Notice before, results after, right to watch 41.3 40.3
Defect found: correct, then repeat the test 41.4 40.4
Supervisor causes no unnecessary delay 41.5 40.5
Cost of a repeat test charged to the Contractor 41.6 40.6
Items tested before delivery 42.1 41.1

In plain English

Give the Supervisor (the person who checks quality for the Client) enough warning to attend. If a test fails because your work is defective, you pay the Client's cost of the retest. If the Supervisor or the Client causes needless delay, you may have a compensation event.

The notice that catches people out

Tell the Supervisor early enough that the test can be set up and done before the next trade hides the work. The clause gives no number of days, so the Scope should. The risk shows up if you cover work untested and the Supervisor then orders a search. A search that finds no Defect is usually a compensation event in your favour, but not when it only arose because you gave too little notice. Think of a screed laid over pipework before the pressure test was witnessed.

Three compensation events to know

  • 60.1(10): the Supervisor orders a search and finds nothing wrong.
  • 60.1(11): the Supervisor's own test or inspection holds you up more than it needed to.
  • 60.1(16): the Client fails to supply what the Scope promised for testing: materials, facilities or samples.

Notice the word "unnecessary" in the second one. A test that takes its fair time is not an event, even if it breaks your sequence. Keep a note of when you asked for attendance and when the Supervisor turned up, because the argument will turn on those two dates.

Who pays for a repeat test

When a Defect leads to a retest, the Project Manager assesses what the repeat cost the Client and you pay it (41.6). That covers items such as the Supervisor's team or a laboratory the Client engages. Your own cost of putting right and retesting is dealt with through your main Option.

Payment tied to a test

Some payments are conditional on a test being passed. If the Supervisor never carries that test out and you are not to blame, the payment still becomes due, though only after the defects date and the last defect correction period have both gone by. That could mean a long wait, so chase the missing test in writing rather than counting on this fallback.

Testing before delivery

If the Scope requires Plant and Materials to pass tests before delivery, keep them off the Working Areas until you hear they have passed. Show that confirmation as its own dated step in the programme.

What to put in the Scope

  1. A schedule of each test and inspection, and who carries it out.
  2. The notice period for each hold point.
  3. Who provides materials, facilities and samples.
  4. Pass criteria that can be measured.
  5. The list of items tested off site, and the place.

Example

A fictional footbridge deck has a cube test that fails. The Contractor recasts the affected pour. The Client's laboratory charges £900 for the retest and the Project Manager assesses that sum against the Contractor. Breaking out and recasting is a separate cost the Contractor carries on a fixed-price Option.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?