Adjudicate now or keep talking? How to choose under NEC
How to decide between adjudication and negotiation on an NEC contract: check running deadlines first, then weigh the evidence, the sum and the relationship.
On this page
You are in a stand-off over money or time, the other side will not move, and you need to decide whether to start adjudication (a fast, binding decision by an independent person) or keep negotiating.
The short answer
Check whether a clock is running before anything else. On W1, or when a final assessment deadline is close, you may have to refer while you are still talking, because the time limit makes the choice for you. On W2 with no deadline close, keep negotiating while it is making progress, and set a date at which you stop. After that, weigh the sum, your evidence and how much you need the other side's goodwill.
What to do, step by step
- Read the deadlines today. Under W1 four weeks is common for disputing an action or inaction, and talking does not stop it. See the time limits guide.
- Check the final assessment. Under NEC4 it becomes conclusive unless a dispute is referred in time, on both W1 and W2. See disagreeing with the final assessment.
- Note the post-decision limit. If you are unhappy with a decision, you have four weeks to notify the tribunal.
- Agree any extension in writing before the period expires.
- Score the situation with the questions below.
- If you want both tracks, run them together as set out after the table.
Ask these seven questions. Each pair shows which way the answer tends to point.
- How is the other side behaving? Engaged and moving suggests talking. Stalling, silence or one fixed line suggests adjudicating.
- What is the question? A valuation with a fair range suits negotiation. A yes-or-no point, such as whether a term applies or a sum is due, suits an Adjudicator.
- How good is your evidence? If it is still being gathered, talk. If it is complete, you are ready, since most of the work happens before the notice.
- How big is the sum? A small amount against referral costs favours talking. A large one justifies fees and management time.
- What is it doing to your cash? If you can carry it, talk. If it hurts, refer.
- Where is the job? Live work with key decisions coming favours keeping the peace. A job near the end, or a relationship already over, frees you to adjudicate.
- How do you feel about risk? Negotiation keeps the result in your hands. Adjudication hands it to a third party within weeks.
Doing both at once
- Write a short position paper with your best figure and the evidence behind it.
- Propose a senior meeting on a fixed date within two weeks. Under NEC4 W2, Senior Representatives (each side's senior person) are available if both agree, with statements in one week and up to three weeks of talks.
- Agree that the discussion is without prejudice, and take advice on how to mark it.
- Build the referral in parallel, so the notice is a real threat and the seven days are not a scramble.
- If the date passes with no movement, serve the notice.
What adjudication means in practice
On W2 you must send the referral within seven days of the notice. The decision is normally due 28 days after that, unless extended, and the responding party has 14 days to add information. See adjudication under NEC. Remember:
- You get one attempt per issue: a dispute substantially the same as one already decided cannot be referred again.
- The decision binds until a tribunal overturns it, so pay or comply first and argue later.
- The Adjudicator's fees are apportioned in the decision. Budget for your own costs as well, and assume you will not recover them.
- The notice sets the scope. A vague description can limit what is decided.
What to record
- Your position paper and the dates it was sent.
- Every offer and reply, marked with whether it is without prejudice.
- The date each deadline runs out and who agreed any extension.
- Your cost estimate for a referral compared with the sum in dispute.
What not to do
- Do not let talks drift past a W1 deadline.
- Do not time a referral for a holiday week to catch the other side out. It wins you no goodwill.
- Do not ignore a notice if you receive one: the Adjudicator can carry on without you, so get help on day one.
- Do not let a final negotiating letter be read as extending a period. State that it does not.
When to get help
Bring in your commercial manager once the sum or the relationship is serious, and a lawyer before the notice of adjudication is drafted. A planner helps when the argument is about delay or programme.
Example
A fictional roofing subcontractor is owed £140,000 across three compensation events on a W2 contract with six months left. Two events turn on whether the Scope covered certain work. One turns on valuation. A senior meeting settles the valuation at £35,000 against the £50,000 claimed. The other two do not move, so it adjudicates only the Scope question, keeping the referral narrow and cheaper. Figures are illustrative.
Related guides
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
