You missed the NEC dispute deadline: can you still refer?

What a missed dispute deadline means under W1 and W2, which other time limits can still catch you, and how to check where you stand before doing anything else.

Disputes and terminationScenario4 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

You disagreed with a decision some weeks ago, and now you realise the dates may have slipped. Whether that matters depends on the dispute Option in your contract.

The short answer

Under W2 you can normally still refer, because adjudication is open at any time. Under W1, a missed deadline normally closes off both the Adjudicator and the tribunal, unless someone agreed an extension before the date went by. Even on W2 two other limits can bite: the NEC4 final assessment window and any compensation event time bar that has already run. So first work out exactly which deadline you missed. The periods below are taken from the NEC4 subcontract wording and the NEC3 ECC. The NEC4 ECC is built the same way, but your own W clause governs.

What to do, step by step

  1. Check the Contract Data to see whether you are on W1, W2 or W3.
  2. Name the matter in dispute. Is it an action or inaction of the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day), something treated as accepted, a final assessment, or something else? The deadline depends on the category.
  3. Establish when you became aware, using paperwork rather than recollection.
  4. Check for Z clauses (the contract's own amendments), which often alter these provisions.
  5. If time is still running, refer now, or get a written extension agreed before the deadline.
  6. If time has gone, take legal advice before sending anything that concedes the point.

How the Options differ:

  • W2: adjudication can start at any time, so missing a period is no bar under the Option's own terms. After a decision you still have four weeks to notify the tribunal. For a final assessment in NEC4, you must refer within four weeks or it becomes conclusive.
  • W1: you must act within the stated periods. NEC4 sends you through the Senior Representatives first, with four weeks from awareness for an action or inaction. NEC3 gives four weeks to notify, then two to four to refer. If the date is missed, that matter cannot go to the Adjudicator or the tribunal for either side. Extensions work only when agreed before the notice or referral is due.

The time limits guide has the full tables.

What to record

  • The decision you dispute, with its date and the clause it was made under.
  • The evidence of when you first knew.
  • Every deadline you think applies, and how you calculated it.
  • Any extension request and reply.
  • The wording of your original notice, if any.

What not to do

  • Do not assume W2 rescues everything. Being able to refer is not the same as winning. If you also missed the eight weeks for notifying a compensation event, an Adjudicator will see a claim the contract treats as late. See missing the eight-week deadline.
  • Do not dress up the same point as a fresh dispute to dodge a W1 bar; that tends to fail.
  • Do not write an admission while you are still checking your position.
  • Do not forget the separate limitation period in general law, which is an outer limit on legal action.

When to get help

Speak to a lawyer or an experienced commercial manager the moment you suspect a W1 deadline has passed, because the options are then narrow. Check whether the matter is really time-limited, since "any other matter" can be referred once the dispute arises. Check your awareness date honestly. See whether a later, genuinely separate decision raises its own question. And remember that nothing stops both sides agreeing a commercial settlement. The other side will probably say you are out of time and may challenge the Adjudicator's jurisdiction. Refusing a timely extension request purely for advantage is poor practice, although nobody can force agreement.

For a W1 extension, a short letter does the job: identify the decision and your awareness date, state when the period ends, ask for it to move to a named date, and ask for written confirmation before that date.

Example

A fictional steelwork subcontractor is told on 3 March that its event is not a compensation event. Its commercial manager is on leave and nothing happens until mid-May.

  • On W2 it can give notice of adjudication in May and refer within seven days.
  • On NEC4 W1 the four-week window to reach the Senior Representatives closed around 31 March. With no extension agreed in time, it is shut out.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?