What to do if you disagree with the NEC final assessment
Four weeks decide whether you can challenge the final assessment under NEC. Learn the clock, the referral route and what to put in writing.
On this page
The final assessment has landed and the number is wrong, or at least not yours. The Project Manager (the person who runs the contract for the Client) has set what is finally owed, and you now have a short window to push back.
The short answer
Start the dispute route within four weeks of the date the assessment was issued. After that, under NEC4 clause 53.3, the figure becomes conclusive evidence of what is finally owed. Do not use those four weeks on talks alone. Diarise the last date the day you receive it, and refer to the right body, which depends on whether you have Option W1 or W2 (the dispute resolution options) and whether the assessment was issued on time.
What to do, step by step
- Note the issue date and the date it should have been issued. The Project Manager has four weeks from the Defects Certificate, or thirteen weeks after a termination certificate (53.1).
- Work out your latest referral date, and set an internal deadline well before it.
- Refer the disagreement in writing within the four weeks:
| Your contract | Where it goes first |
|---|---|
| Option W1 | The Senior Representatives (senior people nominated by each side) |
| Option W2, the usual choice where the Construction Act applies | The Senior Representatives or straight to the Adjudicator |
| Option W3 | The steps in that Option, read with 53.3 |
- If you use the Senior Representatives, the NEC4 subcontract text gives them up to three weeks to produce a list of what is agreed and not agreed. Refer anything unresolved to the Adjudicator within three weeks of that list, or of when it should have appeared.
- If you are unhappy with the Adjudicator's decision, refer that dissatisfaction to the tribunal within four weeks, otherwise the decision is folded into the assessment (53.4).
- Where you reach agreement on part, record it in writing. Agreement changes the assessment.
These periods come from the NEC4 subcontract, which uses ECC numbering. Check your own contract and Z clauses first.
What to record
- The issue date, how it was sent and who sent it.
- A schedule showing your figure against theirs, item by item.
- Evidence of any compensation event omitted, and when you notified it.
- Cost records for any Disallowed Cost argument on Options C to E.
- Minutes and emails from every without-prejudice style discussion, so you can show dates.
What not to do
- Do not assume a late assessment has no effect. Treat the four weeks as running and say in writing that it was late.
- Do not wait for a final meeting if one is dragging. Referral protects the date, and talks can carry on.
- Do not reopen a compensation event that was already implemented. An implemented assessment is not revised (66.3).
- Do not agree an extension unless the contract allows it, and always record it.
When to get help
Involve your commercial manager at once. Take legal advice if the sum is significant, or if the issue turns on whether the assessment was within time, since late issue changes the position. If the Project Manager issues nothing, you may issue your own assessment with the working behind it (53.2).
Example
A fictional Option C road contract receives its final assessment on 20 May, which leaves out £90,000 of your costs. The last referral date is 17 June. Your commercial manager and the other side's agree £40,000 by 10 June. You refer the remaining £50,000 on 12 June and note the £40,000 in writing, so only the £50,000 goes forward.
Related guides
- The final assessment
- Time limits for NEC disputes
- Adjudication under NEC
- Open compensation events after the project ends
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
