Pain/gain share in NEC: what you keep and what you hand back

A plain walk through the contractor's share on NEC Options C and D, with a worked table and the point where your margin disappears.

NEC Options and contract types3 min read

On this page
  1. One invented job, three outcomes
  2. Three things this shows
  3. What pain/gain does not do
  4. Questions to ask before tender is submitted
  5. Related guides

"Pain/gain" is everyday shorthand, not a term the contract uses. It describes the Contractor's share on Options C and D: if the job costs less than the target, you and the Client split the saving, and if it costs more, you split the overrun. The easy part to remember is the split. The part people miss is what the pain side does to your Fee, which is your built-in allowance for overhead and profit.

One invented job, three outcomes

A culvert replacement has a final target of £1,000,000. You carry a flat 50% of any difference and your Fee percentage is 10%. Remember the Price for Work Done to Date is Defined Cost plus Fee, so Defined Cost is that figure divided by 1.1.

  • You come in under. The Price for Work Done to Date is £880,000 (Defined Cost £800,000, Fee £80,000). The saving is £120,000, so you receive £60,000. The Client pays £940,000 in total, and you end up £140,000 above your Defined Cost.
  • You hit target. £1,000,000 is paid, nothing is shared. Defined Cost is about £909,091 and the Fee about £90,909, which is what you keep.
  • You come in over. The figure reaches £1,150,000 (Defined Cost about £1,045,455, Fee about £104,545). The excess is £150,000 and you pay back £75,000. The Client pays £1,075,000 in total and you keep only about £29,545 above Defined Cost.

"What you keep" is just the Client's total payment less Defined Cost. It is not a contract term, and your real costs may differ from Defined Cost.

Three things this shows

Saving still pays you. In the first case the Fee gets smaller than on target, yet the share more than covers it. That is the incentive the target is meant to create.

The overrun eats the Fee first. In the third case you earned over £104,000 of Fee and handed back £75,000 of it, leaving very little for overheads and profit.

There is a point where you start losing money. On these numbers your margin reaches zero at roughly £1,222,222, about 122% of target. Beyond that every extra pound of cost is a straight loss. Your own tipping point depends on your Fee percentage and the shape of the share bands, so calculate it at tender. It tells you how much overrun you can carry before the job turns against you.

What pain/gain does not do

  • It is not paid monthly. You receive Defined Cost plus Fee as you go. The share comes at Completion and in the final amount due.
  • It does not limit the Client's exposure. In the over case the Client paid £75,000 above target, and that could keep growing unless the bands say otherwise.
  • It does not punish you for Client-side change. A properly assessed compensation event moves the target, so it should not count as pain. That only works if your event records are accurate and timely.
  • It does not cover your own mistakes. Cost the Project Manager disallows never reaches the calculation, and you carry all of it. See defined cost, fee and disallowed cost.

Questions to ask before tender is submitted

  1. At what cost does my margin reach zero, and is that plausible for this job?
  2. Has the target been tested so both sides believe it is achievable?
  3. Will we both see cost and the forecast share every month?
  4. Does my supply chain carry any pain or gain of its own, or does it all stop with me?
  5. Can my business absorb the bad-case payment at Completion?

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?