What happens when the Project Manager does not reply: treated acceptance

How NEC treated acceptance works for compensation event decisions, quotations, assessments and programmes, with the notice you must send and the timings.

Compensation events and change3 min read

On this page
  1. In plain English
  2. The four routes in NEC4 ECC
  3. Steps for a quotation
  4. A timeline with new figures
  5. Limits and exceptions
  6. Tips for contractors and subcontractors
  7. What to expect from the other side
  8. Related guides

Silence from the Project Manager can win you the point, but only if you act. In NEC, when the Project Manager (the person the Client appoints to run the contract day to day) misses a reply deadline, you must send a notice about the failure. If they still say nothing two weeks later, the thing you submitted is treated as accepted. No notice from you means no treated acceptance, however late they are.

In plain English

Late is not enough. You have to tell them they are late, in writing, and then wait two more weeks. After that, your quotation counts as agreed.

The four routes in NEC4 ECC

What they missed Normal period After your notice What is treated as agreed Clause
Decision on a notified event 1 week 2 weeks The event is a compensation event and quotations are treated as instructed 61.4
Reply to your quotation 2 weeks 2 weeks Your quotation 62.6
Their own assessment The time you would have had to quote 2 weeks Your quotation 64.4
Reply to a programme 2 weeks A further period The programme (NEC4 only) 31.3

NEC3 has the same idea for quotations and assessments but not for programmes. Z clauses often change the periods, so check yours. The programme route has its own guide.

Steps for a quotation

  1. You submit the quotation. The two-week reply period under 62.3 starts.
  2. The deadline passes and nothing comes back.
  3. You send a separate notification (13.7) that mentions the quotation and the date you submitted it. If you sent several, say which one you propose.
  4. Two more weeks go by without a proper reply.
  5. The quotation is treated as accepted, and the event is implemented (66.1). The Prices and dates change.

A timeline with new figures

Imagine a rail possession job where you submit a quotation for £96,000 and ten days.

Day Event
0 Quotation submitted
14 Reply due, none arrives
15 You notify the failure
29 Two weeks since your notice, still nothing: quotation treated as accepted

Figure 1. The quotation example in days. The £96,000 quotation is submitted on day 0, the two-week reply is due on day 14 and none arrives, you notify the failure on day 15, and if nothing comes by day 29 the quotation is treated as accepted and the event is implemented. A valid reply before day 29 still stops the process.
Figure 1. The quotation example in days. The £96,000 quotation is submitted on day 0, the two-week reply is due on day 14 and none arrives, you notify the failure on day 15, and if nothing comes by day 29 the quotation is treated as accepted and the event is implemented. A valid reply before day 29 still stops the process. Open full size

Until day 29 the Project Manager can still send a valid reply, and that stops the process. After it, a late reply no longer undoes the position, and an implemented event is not normally reopened (66.3).

Limits and exceptions

  • Proposed instructions work the other way. Under NEC4 65.2, silence means the quotation is not accepted.
  • An instructed event is not a priced one. Under 61.4 you get a compensation event and an instruction to quote, but not a sum.
  • Amended contracts. Some clients lengthen the periods or delete treated acceptance, so read your Z clauses.

Tips for contractors and subcontractors

  • Make the notice unmistakable. A polite reminder email may not count.
  • Keep proof of when you sent it, because the two weeks run from that date.
  • Do not inflate a price because you expect silence. A quotation accepted only through silence invites a dispute, and the relationship lasts longer than one event.
  • Remember that a missed reply is also its own compensation event under 60.1(6). You will rarely need both remedies.

What to expect from the other side

A good Project Manager treats your notice as urgent, because they still have two weeks. A holding letter saying "under review" is not one of the permitted answers and may not stop the clock. Leave is no excuse either, as the periods keep running unless someone is delegated to act.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?