No reply to your quotation: using clause 62.6

How to turn a Project Manager's silence on your quotation into a treated acceptance, with the deadlines for the ECC and the NEC4 subcontract.

Compensation events and changeScenario3 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What to do, step by step
  3. What to record
  4. What not to do
  5. When to get help
  6. Example
  7. Related guides

You submitted a quotation for a compensation event and the reply date has passed. The Project Manager has not accepted, rejected or answered it.

The short answer

Once the reply date has gone, give the Project Manager a failure notice under clause 62.6. If no proper answer follows within a further two weeks on the ECC, the contract treats the quotation as accepted and the Prices and dates change. Silence on its own achieves nothing. NEC3 treats the ECC the same way.

What to do, step by step

  1. Work out when you submitted and how long they had. Clause 62.3 sets the time, subject to any Z clause. Clause 62.5 allows an extension only if agreed before the reply falls due.
  2. Make sure no genuine reply exists. An instruction to revise the quotation, or a message saying the Project Manager will assess it, would be one.
  3. Send the failure notice on its own (clause 13.7), identifying the quotation, and the preferred one if you gave alternatives.
  4. Diary the two weeks from the notice.
  5. Confirm the outcome in writing at the end of the period, then update your register, the Prices and the Completion Date, and carry the sum into your next application for payment.
  6. Show the effect in your next programme.
Stage ECC (NEC3 and NEC4) NEC4 subcontract
Time for them to reply to a quotation (62.3) Two weeks after submission Four weeks after submission
Extra time after your failure notice (62.6) Two weeks Three weeks

A sample notice, invented: "Quotation Q-051 for compensation event CE-066, submitted on 9 September, asks for £18,600 and a Completion Date four days later. The reply was due on 23 September and we have none. We give notice of that failure under clause 62.6 and note that, if it lasts two more weeks, the quotation is treated as accepted."

What to record

  • The quotation and the proof of when it was submitted.
  • Any agreed extension.
  • The failure notice and when it was sent.
  • Any reply received, with the date.

What not to do

  • Do not treat silence as acceptance without sending the notice.
  • Do not accept "under review" as a listed reply. It is not one, and you can say so.
  • Do not submit a figure with a known error. Fix it before the period ends.
  • Do not push an inflated number through this route. The contract does not demand that your figure be reasonable, but a quotation well above value can damage the relationship and invite disputes on other events.

When to get help

Bring in a commercial manager if the Project Manager answers within the two weeks. That is its right and it ends the route. Take legal advice if the Client later claims it never agreed the figure: a treated acceptance implements the event under clause 66.1, and an implemented assessment changes only as the conditions allow (66.3, or 65.2 in NEC3). Dispute is still open to the Client, though W1 gives it little time.

Situations that change the answer:

Situation Result
It priced a proposed instruction Opposite result: NEC4 65.2 says no answer means not accepted
You were told to revise, with reasons That is a proper reply; the ECC gives you three weeks to resubmit
The Project Manager said it would assess but has not The failure route sits in 64.3 and 64.4 instead
Amendments in the Z clauses Some stretch these periods or delete the route

Example

You submit on 9 September, the answer is due 23 September, and you send your failure notice on 24 September. With no valid reply by 8 October, the quotation is treated as accepted: the Prices rise by £18,600 and the Completion Date moves four days.

Figure 1. The example on one axis. Quotation Q-051 for £18,600 and four days is submitted on 9 September, the two-week reply is due on 23 September and none comes, the failure notice goes on 24 September, and on 8 October the quotation is treated as accepted. On the NEC4 subcontract the two periods are four weeks and three weeks instead.
Figure 1. The example on one axis. Quotation Q-051 for £18,600 and four days is submitted on 9 September, the two-week reply is due on 23 September and none comes, the failure notice goes on 24 September, and on 8 October the quotation is treated as accepted. On the NEC4 subcontract the two periods are four weeks and three weeks instead. Open full size

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?