Can you recover a sharp rise in material prices under NEC?
A material price rise is not a compensation event. See whether Option X1 helps, how each main Option shares the cost, and what to do now.
On this page
Steel, aggregate or pipe has jumped in price since you tendered, and you want to know whether the contract lets you pass the increase on.
The short answer
Not as a claim in its own right. A material price rise is not a compensation event, and the core NEC clauses give no general right to recover it. Whether any of it comes back depends on whether Option X1 (price adjustment for inflation) is in your contract and which main Option you are on. Check your Contract Data and any Z clauses first, before spending time on arguments.
What to do, step by step
- Check the contract. Look in the Contract Data for X1 and in the Z clauses (project-specific amendments) for anything on fluctuations. Note the base date and the index proportions.
- Work out who carries the rise. Use the table below.
- Quantify it. Collect today's quotations, your tender allowance and the quantities left to buy, and split out what you already own.
- Fix prices where you can. Early orders, longer supplier agreements and stock in hand often matter more than any contractual argument.
- Consider an early warning. Under NEC4 clause 15.1, either side can flag a risk of higher total cost to you, even where the Prices would stay the same. It is optional, but it opens the conversation.
- Look for savings to propose. Clause 16 is the NEC4 route for suggesting a Scope change that reduces cost. On Options A and B an accepted proposal trims the Prices by just the value engineering share of the saving (63.12). On C and D it does not change them at all (63.13), so you benefit through the share.
- Look for genuine events. If the Client's late information pushed your purchasing into a dearer market, the extra cost may form part of that compensation event, provided you can show the link. The notification limit is eight weeks (seven under the NEC4 ECS).
| Main Option | Without X1 | With X1 |
|---|---|---|
| A or B (priced) | You carry it | An inflation amount, worked out by index, is added to payments |
| C or D (target) | You are paid the higher Defined Cost, but the target is unchanged, so the overrun is split by the share percentages | The target follows the index, leaving only the difference to be shared |
| E (cost reimbursable) | The Client pays Defined Cost plus Fee; X1 is not used | Not available |
| F (management) | Depends on subcontract route; X1 is not used | Not available |
X1 pairs only with Options A to D, and it works from published indices. A spike that outruns your chosen index leaves you with the gap.
What to record
- Tender prices, supplier quotations at tender and today's.
- Dates of orders, deliveries and price notifications from suppliers.
- Quantities bought and still to buy.
- Any Client delay that moved your purchase date.
What not to do
- Do not argue the prevention event (clause 60.1(19)). A price rise does not stop you completing, it only costs more.
- Do not load an unrelated compensation event quotation with the rise. A quotation reflects the forecast cost of that event alone.
- Do not rely on a meeting note if the Client agrees anything. Under clause 12.3 a change needs agreement, written confirmation and signatures from both parties.
When to get help
Involve your commercial manager before writing to the Client. Ask a planner if delay shifted your purchase dates.
Example
A fictional stone-supply job. You priced 500 tonnes of rock armour at £40 and now pay £52, an overrun of £6,000. On Option A without X1, you absorb £6,000. On Option C with a 50% Contractor share and nothing else pushing cost over target, you pay about £3,000. With X1, an index rise of 20% on a 10% material weighting would add roughly 2% of the whole price to payments, not tied to your invoices.
Expect "no" first: the Prices are fixed and you priced the risk. That is correct on the contract. A public Client may say it cannot pay for what the contract omits. A private one may listen if the job is at risk, though it will probably ask for something back.
For future tenders, price volatile materials openly or ask for X1. It cannot be added after signing without an agreed change.
Related guides
- X1: price adjustment for inflation
- We priced the job wrong
- Target cost and the Contractor's share
- What should be an early warning?
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
