Another contractor is holding you up: can you claim?
When delay by the Client's other contractors, utilities or authorities is a compensation event, and why your Accepted Programme usually decides it.
On this page
Someone else on or near the site is not finishing when you need them to, and your own work is blocked. You are not sure whether that is your problem or the Client's.
The short answer
It is the Client's risk if it fits clause 60.1(5): the Client or Others (parties outside the contract, such as the Client's separate contractors, utilities and authorities) are working outside the times on your Accepted Programme (the programme the Project Manager has accepted), outside conditions in the Scope, or doing Site work the Scope doesn't mention. Your first step is to check what the Accepted Programme says about their work, because that often settles it. NEC3 refers to Employer and Works Information.
What to do, step by step
- Check they really are Others. The Client's separate contractor, a utility, a local authority or a neighbour usually is. Your own subcontractor or supplier is not, and neither is anyone you employ directly. Their delay is your risk.
- Pull up the Accepted Programme current today. Find their activity and dates. Your programme must show the Client's and Others' work as last agreed (clause 31.2), so this is your baseline.
- Read the Scope for conditions on their work: hours, sequence, shared space, or a statement of what they will do.
- Give an early warning as soon as you see them slipping (clause 15.1), and ask for a meeting with them present.
- Notify the compensation event. You may notify one you expect. If you are already late, remember the eight weeks from awareness (clause 61.3, seven under the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Subcontract).
- Keep working where you sensibly can. You must co-operate with Others and share the Working Areas as the Scope says (clause 25.1), and the assessment assumes a competent, prompt response (clause 63.9).
What to record
- Their attendance on site, and what remains undone
- The activity you could not start, with the date it was due to start
- Resources you moved elsewhere, and what that cost
- Dated photographs and joint meeting notes. They carry more weight than opinion
- Any programme revision that changed their dates
What not to do
- Do not update Others' dates on a revised programme without a notified event behind it. If that revision is accepted, the current programme is what the delay is measured against and your event becomes much harder to make out (clause 63.5).
- Do not stay silent about slippage. The Project Manager can say a warning could have been given and assess the event as if it had (clauses 61.5 and 63.7).
- Do not hide your own lateness. If your work wasn't ready anyway, the delay may not have caused your loss.
- Do not expect the other contractor to pay you. You have no contract with them. Your route is through the Project Manager.
When to get help
If the Accepted Programme shows nothing about their work and the Scope merely states they will do it with no dates, the case is harder and needs a commercial manager's view. Ask a planner to model the effect where your work and theirs interface.
Example
A water treatment works on Option A. The Client's controls contractor must finish cable containment before you close the plant room ceiling.
| What the documents show | Likely result |
|---|---|
| Accepted Programme shows containment done by 12 May, finished 2 June | Event: outside the programmed times |
| Programme silent, Scope says they will do it, no dates | Harder to show. No time to measure against |
| Neither mentions them, and they disrupt your work | Event: Site work not stated in the Scope |
| Later accepted revision moved their date to 2 June | Probably no event. The current programme has moved |
Related guides
- Client or others not working as stated
- Programme and compensation events
- Main contractor's delays are costing me time
- Early warning notice template
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.
