Retention under NEC: when it applies and when you get it back

How NEC retention under Option X16 works, with a worked example, the release trigger, retention bonds and the points contractors often miss.

Payment and cost4 min read

On this page
  1. How the clauses work
  2. Worked example
  3. Take over before Completion
  4. Retention bonds in NEC4
  5. Retention in a subcontract
  6. What people get wrong
  7. In plain English
  8. Related guides

Under the full NEC contracts, money is only held back as retention if Option X16 is in your contract. If it is, a stated percentage of the value above a free amount is withheld from what you are owed, half is released at Completion, and the rest comes back once the defects period is over. The short contracts (ECSC and ECSS) have their own rule, clause 50.7 in NEC4. X16 is not used with Option F.

You will find the free amount and the percentage in the Contract Data, the part of the contract where project figures are filled in. The free amount can be zero, in which case retention bites from the very first pound.

How the clauses work

  • X16.1: retention equals the percentage applied to whatever part of the Price for Work Done to Date lies above the free amount. It applies until Completion, or until the Client takes over the whole of the works.
  • X16.2: half the retention is released, then the remainder later. NEC3 halves it in the assessment made at Completion and releases the rest after the Defects Certificate is issued. The NEC4 subcontract text, as amended in 2019, halves it in the next assessment after Completion and releases the rest when the Defects Certificate has become due.
  • X16.3: a retention bond can replace retention. NEC4 only.

The word "due" matters: if the Defects Certificate is late, release should not wait for it. NEC has issued amendments, so confirm the current wording of your own copy.

Worked example

A fictional NEC4 Option A fencing contract with a £200,000 free amount and retention at 5%.

When Price for Work Done to Date Working Held
Month 2 £150,000 Below the free amount £0
Month 6 £600,000 5% of the £400,000 above the line £20,000
Last assessment before Completion £1,000,000 5% of £800,000 £40,000
Next assessment after Completion £1,000,000 Half released £20,000
Once the defects stage has passed £1,000,000 Balance released £0

Nothing is paid out as a separate transaction. The deduction simply disappears from the calculation, and the amount due rises by that sum.

Take over before Completion

Should the Client move into the entire site ahead of Completion, that event becomes the trigger instead. Taking over only part of the works does not reduce retention under X16, even if Option X5 (sectional completion) is also in the contract, because X16 speaks of the whole. Releasing retention section by section needs a Z clause, a project-specific amendment.

Retention bonds in NEC4

Under X16.3, where the data permits or the paying side agrees, you can offer a bond from an accepted bank or insurer covering the full amount to be retained, in the form the Scope sets out. What has already been held is paid in the next assessment. A bank or insurer can be rejected if its standing is not strong enough. Bonds cost money, so weigh the premium against having the cash.

Retention in a subcontract

A subcontract may carry its own X16 with different figures. On cost-based main Options, what the Contractor holds from its subcontractor should not reduce the Defined Cost passed upward. The final release on a subcontract can fall long after that package finished, so a groundworks firm may wait a good while for its money.

What people get wrong

  • Mixing it up with the first-programme hold. The quarter withheld under clause 50.5 is unrelated and stops once a compliant programme is in.
  • Assuming a ring-fenced account. X16 does not require one. If the Client becomes insolvent, retention is generally just a debt. A Z clause can improve protection, and NEC and the Construction Leadership Council have published guidance.
  • Taking the percentage of the whole value. Only the excess over the free amount counts.
  • Never checking the release. Look for it in the assessment after each trigger. A stale deduction can sit unnoticed in a spreadsheet for months.
  • Thinking you need a pay less notice for it. Retention shown correctly in the certificate is already part of the amount due.

In plain English

Retention is a slice held back from your payments, but only above a threshold, and only if X16 is in. Half should come back at Completion and the rest after the defects period.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Check it against your contract.

Was this useful?